Publicaciones CODESEL
Catálogo científico de registros publicados en Zenodo
Directorio de autores
Almansa Jiménez, Fernando
2 publicaciones
ORCID 0009-0006-5528-8808Blasco Lisa, Sandra
2 publicaciones
ORCID 0000-0002-4365-3007Brox Sáenz de la Calzada, Alicia
10 publicaciones
ORCID 0000-0001-5332-1009Castro Milla, José Manuel
12 publicaciones
ORCID 0009-0001-1593-9286Cisneros Cristóbal, Paula
10 publicaciones
ORCID 0000-0002-7894-826XCosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel
43 publicaciones
ORCID 0000-0001-5785-7310Fernández González, Javier
5 publicaciones
ORCID 0009-0003-3909-7540Herrero García, José Luis
10 publicaciones
ORCID 0009-0000-4233-0866Hossain-Lopez, Sheima
1 publicaciones
ORCID 0000-0003-2736-4181Laína Gallego, José María
4 publicaciones
ORCID 0000-0002-7961-9839Lopez Perez, Fernando
10 publicaciones
ORCID 0000-0002-9303-1839Martínez de Baños Martínez de Morentín, Antonio
4 publicaciones
ORCID 0009-0003-6281-6697Muñoz García, Sergio David
1 publicaciones
Pereira Bravo, Fernando
3 publicaciones
ORCID 0009-0006-2928-7860Redondo Gil, Carlos
4 publicaciones
ORCID 0009-0000-4396-8220Segura García, Germán
1 publicaciones
ORCID 0009-0008-3864-4174Serrano García, Eugenio
3 publicaciones
ORCID 0009-0006-5652-6863Hemeroteca del Boletín CODESEL
Número 10 · 2026
14 artículos
Número 9 · 2026
13 artículos
Número 8 · 2026
16 artículos
Número 7 · 2026
13 artículos
Número 6 · 2025
11 artículos
Número 5 · 2025
11 artículos
Número 4 · 2025
11 artículos
Número 3 · 2025
11 artículos
Número 2 · 2025
10 artículos
Número 1 · 2025
11 artículos
Dossiers temáticos CODESEL
Selección automática basada en las palabras clave existentes en Zenodo; clasificación orientativa.
121 publicaciones encontradas
El uso de drones armados autónomos y su encaje en el Derecho Internacional de los Conflictos Armados: avances recientes en el seno de Naciones Unidas
2025Autoría: Lopez Perez, Fernando ORCID ↗
Leer resumen
Legal Review of “El uso de drones armados autónomos y su encaje en el Derecho Internacional de los Conflictos Armados: avances recientes en el seno de Naciones Unidas,” by Fernando López Pérez (CODESEL Bulletin, Vol. 1, No. 5, October 2025)
Fernando López Pérez’s article delivers a meticulous and forward-looking analysis of the normative challenges posed by autonomous armed drones within the framework of International Humanitarian Law (IHL). As part of the CODESEL Bulletin’s October 2025 issue, it contributes significantly to the doctrinal debate surrounding the ethical, legal, and operational implications of lethal autonomous weapon systems (LAWS), particularly in light of recent United Nations developments. The paper stands out for its clarity in connecting the rapidly evolving technological domain of artificial intelligence with the enduring humanitarian principles that underpin the law of armed conflict.
From the outset, López Pérez draws a crucial distinction between remotely piloted drones, operated by humans, and autonomous drones, capable of selecting and engaging targets without direct human input once programmed. This differentiation forms the analytical backbone of the article, allowing the author to trace how each category interacts with the cardinal principles of IHL: distinction, proportionality, and precaution. While he acknowledges that human-operated drones can, in theory, conform to IHL if used within lawful parameters, he underscores that autonomous systems raise profound questions about accountability, predictability, and moral agency in warfare.
The author situates his argument within the framework of ongoing multilateral efforts, particularly the UN Secretary-General’s 2024 Report on Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems (A/79/88) and the UN General Assembly Resolution 79/62 (2024). López Pérez’s treatment of these documents is both descriptive and critical. He identifies the 2024 report as a landmark in consolidating international positions and recognizing that machines endowed with autonomous lethal capacity challenge not only operational ethics but also the legal architecture of state responsibility and individual criminal accountability.
His review of national positions—covering Spain, the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Russia, and China—demonstrates a balanced grasp of the geopolitical and legal dimensions of the debate. Spain’s adherence to the EU’s dual approach, combining prohibition of certain uses with regulatory development, is presented as a pragmatic and normatively consistent stance. By contrast, the positions of the United States and the United Kingdom, which affirm that existing IHL is technologically neutral and sufficient, are analyzed with subtle criticism. López Pérez contends that their reliance on procedural safeguards (e.g., the U.S. Department of Defense Directive 3000.09) may fail to address deeper ontological issues regarding human control and moral accountability in algorithmic warfare.
The sections on France, Russia, and China enrich the comparative framework. France’s advocacy for retaining human command authority reflects a continuity with traditional humanitarian principles, while Russia’s and China’s positions reveal the fragmentation of consensus: Russia resists normative innovation, viewing IHL as adequate, while China proposes functional classifications of “acceptable” and “unacceptable” systems, analogous to the 1995 Protocol on Blinding Laser Weapons. López Pérez’s synthesis of these viewpoints underscores the absence of a shared legal definition of what constitutes a “lethal autonomous weapon,” a gap that continues to hinder the codification of binding norms.
A key strength of the article is its attention to the philosophical and ethical dimension underlying legal interpretation. López Pérez echoes the Secretary-General’s declaration that “machines possessing the power and discretion to take human life are politically unacceptable and morally repugnant,” interpreting it as a reaffirmation of the human-centric foundation of IHL. He interprets this stance not as moral rhetoric but as an implicit reaffirmation of the Martens Clause—a safeguard ensuring that emerging technologies remain subject to the “principles of humanity and the dictates of public conscience.”
The article culminates with a realistic assessment of the 2026 horizon for negotiating a binding legal instrument on autonomous weapons. López Pérez acknowledges that divergent state positions and definitional ambiguities make immediate codification unlikely. Nonetheless, his analysis identifies a growing normative convergence around the concept of human oversight as a minimum legal and ethical threshold. This insight is particularly relevant given the current proliferation of semi-autonomous systems in the conflicts of Nagorno-Karabakh, Ukraine, and Gaza, where algorithmic targeting increasingly challenges the feasibility of ensuring human control.
Methodologically, López Pérez’s article demonstrates a disciplined use of primary legal sources (UN documents, the CCW framework, and ICRC commentaries) and integrates them with contemporary press and academic references. His structured, multi-level approach—linking technological development, normative interpretation, and moral reasoning—exemplifies the analytical rigour required for contemporary IHL scholarship.
In conclusion, the study reaffirms that technological neutrality cannot substitute ethical accountability. López Pérez convincingly argues that the debate on autonomous drones is not about whether machines can comply with IHL, but whether delegating lethal decision-making to algorithms erodes the human essence of humanitarian law itself. His conclusion—“the autonomous selection of human beings as military targets is a moral line that must never be crossed”—encapsulates the article’s profound ethical clarity and its fidelity to the spirit of Geneva.
La Operación Barkhane: evolución, actores y balance de la intervención militar francesa en el Sahel
2025Autoría: Castro Milla, José Manuel ORCID ↗
Leer resumen
Legal and Strategic Review of “Operación Barkhane: evolución, actores y balance de la intervención militar francesa en el Sahel,” by Lieutenant Colonel José Manuel Castro Milla (CODESEL Bulletin, Vol. 1, No. 5, October 2025)
Lieutenant Colonel José Manuel Castro Milla’s “Operación Barkhane: evolución, actores y balance de la intervención militar francesa en el Sahel” stands as one of the most comprehensive and balanced Spanish-language analyses of France’s counterterrorism engagement in the Sahel from a legal and doctrinal standpoint. The study—published in the CODESEL Bulletin—successfully integrates military operational history with international law and strategic policy, providing a nuanced understanding of how the Barkhane operation both shaped and reflected the evolving architecture of collective security in the Sahelian region.
From a legal perspective, Castro Milla frames Opération Barkhane within the continuum of legitimate self-defense and international cooperation under Articles 51 and 52 of the UN Charter, as well as the consent-based deployment agreements between France and the G5 Sahel states (Mali, Niger, Chad, Burkina Faso, and Mauritania). The article astutely highlights that Barkhane’s legal foundation was not anchored in a UN Security Council mandate but rather in bilateral accords, thus situating it within the grey zone between peace enforcement and military assistance. This framework underscores the operation’s sui generis nature as a “semi-autonomous stabilization mission,” bound by both French constitutional law and the principles of the jus ad bellum.
Castro Milla’s juridical approach aligns with the interpretative method of the Institut de Droit International, emphasizing that the legitimacy of military intervention hinges not solely on formal authorization but on the principles of necessity, proportionality, and the protection of human security. The analysis convincingly argues that France sought to balance these obligations while facing the strategic complexity of hybrid actors—ranging from jihadist insurgencies (AQIM, JNIM, ISGS) to local militias and private military entities.
The article’s historical narrative is methodically structured, tracing the transformation from Opération Serval (2013) to Barkhane (2014–2022), and ultimately to Opération Éclipse and the European-led Takuba Task Force. Castro Milla situates these transitions within the broader context of shifting French foreign policy—from direct intervention to multilateral delegation—analyzing their implications for both the doctrine of responsabilité de protéger (R2P) and the operational realities of asymmetric warfare.
One of the most insightful contributions lies in the author’s examination of the operational-legal interface. Castro Milla articulates how Barkhane operated at the intersection of IHL and human rights law, particularly regarding the conduct of airstrikes, the use of intelligence in targeting, and civilian protection obligations. His discussion of the 2021 Bounti incident (in which French airstrikes were alleged to have caused civilian casualties) reflects a sophisticated awareness of the growing tension between military necessity and humanitarian accountability. The author rightly identifies this as a paradigm case for assessing the application of the principle of distinction under Articles 48–51 of Additional Protocol I.
Furthermore, Castro Milla examines Barkhane’s role as a legal precedent for the European Union’s external security posture. The article highlights how EU missions such as EUTM Mali and EUCAP Sahel became integrated into a broader regional security ecosystem, albeit without unified command, thereby exposing the fragmentation of Europe’s Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP). The study’s critical tone toward this institutional incoherence is both timely and justified, as it reveals the juridical and operational consequences of relying on ad hoc coalitions in lieu of supranational mandates.
In its final sections, the article transitions from doctrinal analysis to strategic evaluation, addressing the political repercussions of France’s gradual withdrawal and the entry of Russian private military companies (notably Wagner). Castro Milla interprets this shift as a failure of the West to consolidate a legitimate and sustainable security order in the Sahel, despite the apparent tactical successes of Barkhane. He insightfully links this outcome to the erosion of the consent paradigm, emphasizing that the legitimacy of any foreign deployment depends on the perception of sovereignty by the host state’s population.
Methodologically, the article demonstrates a commendable balance between juridical rigour and operational understanding. The author, drawing upon his military expertise, contextualizes doctrinal sources—such as NATO AJP 3.4.1, the ICRC’s Customary IHL Study, and French defense white papers—within a framework accessible to both legal scholars and military professionals. His references to field data and official communiqués reinforce the credibility of his conclusions, while the language remains precise and devoid of political bias.
In essence, Castro Milla’s contribution transcends descriptive military historiography: it provides a doctrinal anatomy of modern expeditionary warfare within the constraints of IHL and the evolving geopolitics of Africa. By articulating the legal ambiguities and operational paradoxes of Opération Barkhane, the study invites a broader reflection on the future of international military cooperation, the normative resilience of humanitarian law, and the legitimacy of unilateral or coalition-based interventions in the Global South.
La regulación de los espías en el Derecho de los Conflictos Armados y sus consecuencias penales en nuestro país
2025Autoría: Herrero García, José Luis ORCID ↗
Leer resumen
Legal Review of “La regulación de los espías en el Derecho de los Conflictos Armados y sus consecuencias penales en nuestro país,” by José Luis Herrero García (CODESEL Bulletin, Vol. 1, No. 5, October 2025)
José Luis Herrero García’s study, published in the fifth issue of the CODESEL Bulletin, delivers a comprehensive and historically grounded examination of espionage under International Humanitarian Law (IHL) and its subsequent reflection within Spanish criminal and military law. The article succeeds in bridging doctrinal tradition with contemporary practice, offering a coherent synthesis that extends from the Lieber Code (1863) to the modern framework established by the Hague Regulations (1907) and Additional Protocol I (1977).
From a doctrinal perspective, Herrero’s work distinguishes itself by situating espionage as a legally tolerated—though perilous—activity under IHL. The author rightly emphasizes that espionage, while not per se prohibited, entails the loss of combatant and prisoner-of-war status when conducted clandestinely or under false pretenses, as established by Articles 29–31 of the 1907 Hague Regulations and Article 46 of Additional Protocol I. The four defining elements he enumerates—collection of information, location of activity, intent to transmit it to the enemy, and the clandestine or deceptive nature of the act—are presented with clarity and doctrinal precision, aligning with the interpretative approach of the ICRC’s Commentary on the Additional Protocols (1987).
Herrero’s analysis advances beyond mere restatement by connecting these norms with the broader logic of jus in bello. He underlines the nuanced boundary between legitimate military intelligence and prohibited espionage, especially in cases where uniformed messengers or reconnaissance officers act openly—an interpretation consistent with Rule 107 of Customary IHL. The author successfully demonstrates that the central legal distinction rests not on the act of intelligence gathering itself, but on the violation of good faith and transparency that defines espionage as an act of perfidy rather than of warfare.
A particularly valuable aspect of the article lies in its treatment of the “espía-militar” (military spy). Herrero accurately explains that a captured combatant engaged in clandestine intelligence loses prisoner-of-war status only if apprehended in flagrante delicto. Conversely, once a spy successfully rejoins his forces, later capture cannot retroactively invalidate his protection under the Third Geneva Convention. This balanced interpretation mirrors both historical precedent (Lieber Code, art. 104) and contemporary treaty law (AP I, arts. 45–46).
The second half of the article turns to the Spanish domestic legal framework, where Herrero provides a meticulous commentary on the Código Penal Militar (CPM) and Código Penal (CP). His differentiation between espionage (art. 25 CPM)—reserved for foreign agents in wartime—and treason (arts. 583–584 CP)—applied to nationals—is analytically sharp. By examining both the substantive and procedural dimensions, including aggravating and exculpatory clauses (arts. 26, 31, and 33 CPM), Herrero situates the Spanish legal order within a comparative international context. The analysis reveals how Spanish military law internalizes the logic of IHL by maintaining a strict distinction between espionage, treason, and the mere revelation of defense-related secrets.
Of particular doctrinal relevance is the author’s explanation of the gradation of culpability: the aggravated offense when committed with intent to assist a foreign power, the corresponding penalties for omission or non-reporting, and the existence of excusas absolutorias when voluntary disclosure prevents consummation. His reference to domestic legislation on classified information (Law 9/1968 on Official Secrets) and to constitutional safeguards for due process demonstrates a robust understanding of the interplay between national security and the rule of law.
The article also briefly acknowledges contemporary challenges—cyberespionage and intelligence conducted beyond the territorial scope of hostilities—implying a continuity between classical espionage and digital intelligence operations. While the study refrains from detailed analysis of the lex digitalis, its recognition of cyber dimensions invites future exploration of how IHL might evolve to encompass non-kinetic intelligence activities in cyberspace.
In stylistic and methodological terms, Herrero’s essay is grounded in traditional doctrinal exposition, yet avoids abstraction through constant reference to historical examples—from Mata Hari to the 2021 Russian espionage case in Italy and U.S. prosecutions under the 1917 Espionage Act. This narrative approach strengthens the juridical argument by situating it within a tangible operational and political context.
Ultimately, Herrero reaffirms that espionage occupies an ambiguous but indispensable position within the law of armed conflict: a tolerated breach of wartime etiquette that nonetheless triggers severe legal consequences if exposed. His conclusion—linking the international regime of combatant protection to domestic criminal accountability—reveals the dual function of IHL as both shield and sword: a protective framework for lawful conduct and a basis for penal repression of perfidy.
La verdad como obligación: Rehenes y desaparecidos en la guerra moderna
2025Autoría: Cosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel ORCID ↗
Leer resumen
Legal Review of “La verdad como obligación: Rehenes y desaparecidos en la guerra moderna,” by Dr. Andrés Miguel Cosialls (CODESEL Bulletin, Vol. 1, No. 5, October 2025)
Dr. Andrés Miguel Cosialls’ article “La verdad como obligación: Rehenes y desaparecidos en la guerra moderna” represents one of the most technically rigorous and normatively coherent analyses in recent Spanish-language scholarship on International Humanitarian Law (IHL). The study offers an exhaustive juridical and hermeneutical interpretation of Articles 32 to 34 of Additional Protocol I to the 1949 Geneva Conventions, establishing a clear and logical bridge between humanitarian obligations and the autonomous right to the truth.
From a doctrinal standpoint, Cosialls frames Article 32 not as a mere preambular clause but as a structural norm of contemporary humanitarian law. His reading is both systematic and teleological: Article 32 operates as the conceptual foundation for all subsequent obligations concerning missing persons, shifting the analytical focus from the abstract duties of States to the concrete subjective right of families to know the fate of their relatives. This perspective aligns with the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (Velásquez Rodríguez v. Honduras, 1988) and the United Nations Committee on Enforced Disappearances (Principle No. 7, 2019), confirming the article’s continuous applicability beyond the cessation of hostilities.
The author’s argumentation distinguishes itself by integrating primary sources (ICRC Commentaries, Customary International Humanitarian Law, Sassòli 2024, and relevant ICTY/ICC jurisprudence) into a unified interpretive framework. His thesis—that the right to know transcends the temporal limits of war and persists until each disappearance is resolved—extends the humanitarian rationale of IHL into the post-conflict phase, merging it with transitional justice mechanisms based on truth, memory, and reparation.
Cosialls also advances a nuanced distinction between missing persons and hostages, grounding his differentiation on the element of intentionality. While disappearance may result from chaos or negligence, hostage-taking presupposes deliberate coercion. Yet, the article goes further, recognizing that in modern conflicts—such as Syria, Colombia, or Ukraine—these categories frequently overlap, producing cumulative violations of IHL. His analysis of jurisprudence from Karadžić, Mladić, and Kvočka demonstrates how both practices have evolved from moral wrongs into fully prosecutable international crimes.
Another remarkable contribution is the comparative treatment of IHL across international, non-international, and hybrid armed conflicts. Cosialls identifies the asymmetry of obligations between the Geneva Conventions and Additional Protocol II, critically exposing how legal lacunae in non-international conflicts allow States and non-State actors to evade humanitarian accountability. His call for the universalization of protection mechanisms under customary IHL—particularly Rule 117 on the obligation to search for the missing—reflects a forward-looking interpretation in line with ICRC’s 2024 report International Humanitarian Law and the Challenges of Contemporary Armed Conflicts.
In the penultimate section, the author links the duty of search and truth disclosure with the sphere of international criminal responsibility. Hostage-taking is framed as a war crime under Article 8 of the Rome Statute, while enforced disappearance is treated as a crime against humanity under Article 7. This synthesis of humanitarian and criminal frameworks not only reinforces the normative density of Articles 32–34 but also emphasizes command responsibility under Article 28, highlighting the personal accountability of commanders and political leaders.
From an academic and practical perspective, the article succeeds in reasserting the humanitarian essence of IHL while articulating an operational framework for its enforcement. Its argumentation is both meticulous and evocative, balancing legal precision with moral clarity. The conclusion—that Article 32 is a “permanent mandate of elucidation, documentation, and reparation” binding all parties until every disappearance is resolved—captures the enduring human dimension of humanitarian law in an era marked by hybrid wars, opaque detentions, and digital disinformation.
Papel de la artillería de campaña en Malí: Operaciones Serval (2013-2014) y Barkhane (2014-2022)
2025Autoría: Castro Milla, José Manuel ORCID ↗
Leer resumen
Legal and Political Review
José Manuel Castro Milla, “The Role of Field Artillery in Mali: Operations Serval (2013–2014) and Barkhane (2014–2022)”, CODESEL Bulletin, Vol. 1, No. 5, October 2025, ISSN-e 3045-7750.
Lieutenant Colonel José Manuel Castro Milla presents in this article a sophisticated analysis of the operational and legal dimensions of field artillery in contemporary expeditionary warfare. Focusing on the French-led Operations Serval and Barkhane in Mali, he examines how the artillery arm—traditionally associated with large-scale conventional engagements—adapted its doctrine, technology, and legal oversight to meet the demands of counter-insurgency campaigns conducted under the scrutiny of International Humanitarian Law (IHL) and international public opinion.
From a military-technical perspective, Castro’s argument is grounded in doctrinal precision. He explains how the unique characteristics of the Sahel—vast distances, diffuse enemy formations, and severe logistical constraints—required the integration of intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance (ISR) systems, precision-guided munitions, and mobile artillery platforms such as the CAESAR 155 mm howitzer. The author’s operational narrative highlights the “sensor-to-shooter” dynamic, whereby artillery units became instruments of rapid, coordinated, and legally constrained response. This reflects the modern transformation of artillery from a weapon of massed fires into a discriminating tool of limited but decisive effect.
Legally, the article stands out for its explicit engagement with IHL principles. Castro systematically connects operational practice to the three central principles of the law of armed conflict: military necessity, distinction, and proportionality. His analysis of proportionality is particularly relevant, as it recognizes that the legitimacy of fire missions depends not only on their tactical value but also on their humanitarian impact. He recalls that during Barkhane, rules of engagement required legal consultation before authorizing fire near populated areas—an innovation that embedded legal oversight directly into the operational chain of command. This institutionalization of legal review within military operations represents a significant advance in the implementation of jus in bello norms.
From a political-science standpoint, Castro situates the use of artillery within the broader dynamics of legitimacy and governance in the Sahel. He acknowledges that tactical success achieved through superior firepower did not necessarily translate into strategic or political stability, given the persistence of structural weaknesses in local institutions and the complex interaction between international forces and regional actors. The article thereby links military efficiency to political legitimacy, illustrating how the perceived lawfulness of force projection influences both local acceptance and international support.
The author also anticipates the ethical and communicative dimensions of modern warfare. By emphasizing transparency, accountability, and the recording of collateral-damage assessments, he argues that the artillery officer must now operate as both technician and jurist, ensuring that every fire decision withstands legal and moral scrutiny. This portrayal of the artillery officer as a guarantor of lawful conduct underlines the evolution of professional military ethics in the 21st century.
In conclusion, Castro’s contribution represents an exemplary synthesis of operational realism and legal reasoning. It shows that adherence to international law is not an obstacle to effective military action but a strategic enabler that enhances credibility and sustainability in multinational operations. The article’s clarity, doctrinal rigor, and integration of legal and political insight make it a reference text for jurists, defense scholars, and military practitioners interested in the intersection of force, law, and legitimacy in contemporary armed conflict.
El país donde las mujeres dejaron de existir: Afganistán, cuatro años después de la retirada internacional
2025Autoría: Cisneros Cristóbal, Paula ORCID ↗
Leer resumen
Legal Review of Paula Cisneros Cristóbal’s “Afghanistan: The Country Where Women Ceased to Exist” (CODESEL Bulletin, Vol. 1, No. 5, October 2025, ISSN-e 3045-7750)
Paula Cisneros Cristóbal’s contribution, “Afghanistan: The Country Where Women Ceased to Exist,” published in the CODESEL Bulletin (Vol. 1, No. 5, October 2025), offers a rigorous and comprehensive legal examination of the collapse of human rights in Afghanistan following the 2021 international withdrawal and the re-establishment of the Taliban’s Islamic Emirate.
From the standpoint of Public International Law and International Human Rights Law, Cisneros reconstructs with scholarly precision the institutional evolution of Afghanistan — from the 9/11 terrorist attacks and the adoption of UN Security Council Resolutions 1368 and 1373, which recognized the right of self-defense under Article 51 of the UN Charter, to the promulgation of the 2004 Constitution and its subsequent annulment by the Taliban. This chronological and juridical analysis situates the present regression within the broader context of state collapse and political illegitimacy, identifying the 2020 Doha Agreement as the decisive turning point that stripped the Afghan government of authority and enabled the restoration of a theocratic regime.
The central axis of the article lies in the international legal qualification of Taliban policies as a possible gender apartheid under Article 7 of the Rome Statute, defined as a crime against humanity involving the institutionalized segregation and systematic domination of one group over another on the basis of sex. Cisneros carefully enumerates the treaties violated — including the CEDAW, ICCPR, ICESCR, CRC, CAT, and CRPD — and demonstrates that Afghanistan, despite the lack of recognition of the Taliban Emirate, remains legally bound by these instruments pursuant to the principle of pacta sunt servanda (Article 26, Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties).
The study is notable for its systematic and evidentiary method, correlating concrete human rights violations — such as the prohibition of female secondary and university education, exclusion from employment, restrictions on movement, suppression of public demonstrations, mandatory veiling, corporal punishments, and repeal of the 2009 Law on the Elimination of Violence Against Women — with the specific provisions of the relevant international treaties. This approach grants the article a high level of legal credibility and analytical depth, going beyond descriptive reporting toward juridical substantiation.
Cisneros also develops a dual perspective of international responsibility: on one hand, the continuing state responsibility of Afghanistan for breaches of its conventional obligations; on the other, the individual criminal responsibility of Taliban leaders before the International Criminal Court (ICC). The author notes the 2025 arrest warrants issued against Haibatullah Akhundzada and Abdul Hakim Haqqani for widespread and systematic gender-based persecution, and the proceedings initiated by Germany, Australia, Canada, and the Netherlands before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) for violations of CEDAW.
Methodologically, the article combines normative and documentary analysis with official sources from the United Nations (UNAMA, OHCHR, and the Special Rapporteur Richard Bennett), and integrates recent Security Council resolutions — 2593 (2021), 2681 (2023), and 2721 (2023) — together with academic literature (Schmeidl, 2021; Kakar, 2023). This careful interweaving of legal sources strengthens the paper’s academic authority and positions it as a key reference in contemporary legal scholarship on post-2021 Afghanistan.
In her conclusion, Cisneros asserts that Afghanistan has transformed into a theocratic State devoid of constitutional order, where women have been erased from public and political life. She argues that the international community’s response has been largely symbolic and insufficient, recommending that any diplomatic recognition or lifting of sanctions must remain conditioned upon the restoration of women’s and girls’ fundamental rights.
In essence, this article stands as a doctrinally robust legal study, combining juridical precision with humanitarian insight. It provides a thorough diagnosis of the dismantling of the rule of law in Afghanistan, advances the emerging notion of gender apartheid as an international crime, and contributes meaningfully to the development of a doctrine of international responsibility for gender-based persecution.
U-Space. Una gestión segura y eficiente de espacios aéreos saturados para drones
2025Autoría: Lopez Perez, Fernando ORCID ↗
Leer resumen
Review of “U-Space: A Safe and Efficient Management of Saturated Airspace for Drones”
By Fernando López Pérez | CODESEL Bulletin, Vol. 1, No. 4 (August 2025)
This article presents a well-founded legal analysis of the evolving framework for the regulation of unmanned aircraft systems (UAS) within the European Union, focusing in particular on the concept of U-Space as a structured solution to the growing saturation of urban low-altitude airspace. From the outset, the author identifies the Implementing Regulation (EU) 2021/664 as the cornerstone of this regulatory regime, correctly emphasizing its role in ensuring the safe, efficient, and automated integration of drones into airspace traditionally reserved for manned aviation.
The article’s interpretation of the EU Regulation is legally rigorous. It underlines the importance of automation, digitalization, and procedural harmonization in designated U-Space zones, as established in Recitals 3 and 5 of the Regulation. These zones require specific operational protocols, enhanced monitoring, and structured service provision to guarantee safety and to respect privacy requirements. The author demonstrates an accurate understanding of how these legal imperatives align with the operational complexity of urban drone activity.
Equally valuable is the treatment of Spanish domestic implementation, especially through the Plan de Acción Nacional para el Despliegue de U-Space 2022–2025 and the subsequent Real Decreto 517/2024. The article outlines with clarity the institutional responsibilities assigned to each actor: the Interministerial Commission for Transport and Defence is responsible for designating U-Space zones; the AESA supervises and certifies service providers; and ENAIRE is formally designated as the exclusive provider of Common Information Services (CIS) for a ten-year renewable term. This legal-institutional framework is explained with precision and illustrates how European rules are transposed and operationalized in the Spanish context.
Particularly commendable is the article’s linkage between legal norms and technological functionality. The explanation of U-Space’s components—such as real-time airspace management, geofencing, emergency protocols, and interoperability—shows how legal rules are meant to facilitate the coexistence of drones and manned aircraft under a common digitalized regime. In this regard, the analysis reflects a mature understanding of the convergence between administrative law, airspace sovereignty, and technical innovation.
Nonetheless, the article could have been enriched by addressing data protection concerns. As drone operations inherently involve the processing of potentially sensitive personal data (e.g., images or geolocation), a discussion on compliance with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) would have been relevant. Additionally, some comparative references to other EU Member States' U-Space deployment—such as France or Germany—could have provided broader context and illustrated legal harmonization or divergence.
From a jurist’s perspective, the article is methodologically sound, institutionally precise, and aligned with current regulatory priorities in both EU and Spanish aviation law. It avoids overreliance on technical jargon and succeeds in highlighting the legal implications of a technologically complex domain. The use of primary sources, such as the Regulation itself and the Spanish royal decree, is appropriate and supports the article’s analytical solidity.
In sum, this is a valuable legal contribution to the study of unmanned aviation governance. It provides a clear exposition of the legal architecture of U-Space, demonstrates an understanding of institutional dynamics, and anticipates the operational and legal challenges of airspace saturation. It will be of interest to legal scholars, regulators, and professionals engaged in aviation safety, administrative law, and the regulation of emerging technologies.
VBG-FT. Nuevas Armas y Escenarios para Antiguas Batallas
2025Autoría: Hossain-Lopez, Sheima ORCID ↗
Leer resumen
Review of Article: “GBV-FT: New Weapons and Scenarios for Old Battles”
by Sheima HOSSAIN LÓPEZ, Boletín CODESEL, vol. 1, no. 4 (August 2025)
This article offers a timely and comprehensive legal-analytical exploration of the emerging phenomenon of Gender-Based Violence Facilitated by Technology (TFGBV). Framed within the broader agenda of Women, Peace and Security, and aligned with international instruments such as UN Security Council Resolution 1325 (2000), the article by Sheima Hossain López addresses TFGBV as a novel but increasingly pervasive threat to individual dignity, gender equality, and democratic resilience.
From a legal standpoint, the article achieves several objectives commendable in doctrinal scholarship. First, it provides a functional definition of TFGBV based on UNFPA and national legal developments, particularly the February 2025 update to Spain’s Pacto de Estado contra la Violencia de Género. The concept is defined not merely as digital abuse, but as violence facilitated or aggravated by technology, which allows it to encompass hybrid forms of abuse spanning both virtual and physical realms. This distinction is crucial in legal settings, where typification and proof of conduct rely heavily on contextual elements.
Second, the article highlights several gaps in legal protection and enforcement. It rightly underscores the lack of supranational regulatory frameworks and enforcement mechanisms capable of addressing the transboundary and anonymous nature of TFGBV. The piece refers to challenges posed by the jurisdictional fragmentation of online space, the inadequacy of current criminal definitions, and the difficulty in identifying perpetrators. These legal observations are supported with empirical evidence, including global data on deepfake pornography, cyberstalking, and sextortion, thereby reinforcing the doctrinal foundation of the argument.
Of particular importance is the intersectional lens applied throughout the text. Hossain López places TFGBV within a matrix of multiple forms of discrimination—gender, race, sexual orientation, religion—making it clear that this type of violence exacerbates existing power imbalances and systemic inequalities. This aligns with evolving jurisprudence in human rights law and the obligations of States under CEDAW and the Istanbul Convention.
The legal and policy dimension of the response is also addressed through concrete regulatory developments. The author references the EU Directive 2024/1385 and Spain’s plan to transpose it, thereby bringing the discussion squarely within the domain of positive law. Moreover, the recommendation to develop codes of conduct for technology firms and adopt survivor-centered, rights-based responses resonates with soft-law instruments such as the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises and the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights.
Another strength lies in the article's engagement with the security sector. The author persuasively argues that online misogyny and TFGBV should not be considered marginal social issues but as factors that threaten public safety, democratic participation, and national security. By citing the U.S. Marine Corps University Press and NATO’s updated policy on Women, Peace and Security, the piece elevates the discussion to the strategic level, placing legal responses within a multidimensional framework of deterrence, prevention, and institutional reform.
The article is a significant contribution to both doctrinal legal scholarship and applied policy analysis. It blends legal interpretation, empirical data, and normative recommendations with clarity and precision. The inclusion of multi-layered risk/protection frameworks and comparative regulatory references gives it immediate utility for legislators, legal practitioners, and public authorities alike.