Biblioteca Digital CODESEL

Publicaciones CODESEL

Catálogo científico de registros publicados en Zenodo

121 publicaciones encontradas

EUCAP Somalia: Misión Civil de la UE para el Fortalecimiento de la Seguridad y el Estado de Derecho

2026

Autoría: Castro Milla, José Manuel ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 10 · Páginas: 48-49 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21643032
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Castro Milla, José Manuel. “EUCAP Somalia: Misión Civil de la UE para el Fortalecimiento de la Seguridad y el Estado de Derecho.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 10, August 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

Review

The European Union’s civilian crisis-management missions have become an increasingly important instrument for linking external security policy, institutional capacity-building and the promotion of the rule of law. Somalia provides a particularly demanding environment for this model because maritime insecurity, piracy, organised crime, weak law-enforcement capacity and fragmented political authority interact with a prolonged process of security-sector transition. In this concise and informative article, José Manuel Castro Milla examines the origins, mandate and current functions of EUCAP Somalia, presenting the mission as one of the principal civilian components of the European Union’s integrated security engagement in the Horn of Africa.

The article begins by tracing the institutional evolution of the mission from EUCAP Nestor, established in 2012 as a regional maritime capacity-building initiative covering the Horn of Africa and the Western Indian Ocean. Its original purpose was closely connected with strengthening regional capabilities against piracy. Following the 2016 strategic review, the mission was renamed EUCAP Somalia and its geographical focus was concentrated on Somalia, including activities in Somaliland. This evolution demonstrates the EU’s gradual transition from a broad regional maritime-security approach towards a more focused programme of institutional capacity-building within Somalia itself.

One of the article’s principal strengths lies in its clear explanation of EUCAP Somalia’s dual security and rule-of-law mandate. The mission supports the development of the Somali police, strengthens maritime-security capabilities and assists the Somali authorities in constructing an effective internal-security and legal framework. It therefore operates at the intersection of law enforcement, institution-building and maritime governance rather than functioning as a conventional military mission. This distinction is important for understanding the specific contribution of civilian Common Security and Defence Policy missions to stabilisation.

The extension of the mission’s mandate until February 2027 further demonstrates the European Union’s long-term commitment to institutional consolidation in Somalia. Castro Milla correctly emphasises that EUCAP Somalia seeks not merely to provide operational support but to improve the Somali Federal Police’s capacity to enforce the law and to assist domestic authorities in building sustainable internal-security structures. Maritime security forms part of this broader objective, particularly through the development of capacities necessary for more effective enforcement of maritime law.

Particularly valuable is the article’s discussion of the European Union’s integrated approach. EUCAP Somalia does not operate in isolation. It coordinates with the EU Special Representative for the Horn of Africa, the European Union Delegation in Somalia, EUTM Somalia and EU NAVFOR Operation Atalanta. The mission also works with the United Nations, the African Union and other international actors. This institutional network illustrates one of the defining characteristics of contemporary EU external action: civilian crisis management, military training, maritime operations, diplomacy, development assistance and humanitarian support are increasingly conceived as mutually reinforcing components of a single strategic framework.

The territorial organisation of the mission is similarly significant. With headquarters in Mogadishu, field offices in Somaliland and Puntland and administrative support from Nairobi, EUCAP Somalia is structured to engage with different levels of Somali governance. This decentralised presence is especially important in a political environment characterised by federal structures, autonomous authorities and significant regional differences in institutional capacity.

The article also provides a useful operational description of the mission’s activities. EUCAP Somalia advises, trains and equips the Somali Federal Police while supporting the development of the legal framework for internal-security governance. It additionally promotes cooperation between land-based and maritime police components and other security actors, thereby seeking to improve interoperability across institutions that might otherwise operate in isolation.

Maritime security constitutes one of the study’s most important dimensions. Castro Milla explains how the mission provides support to regional maritime police forces in Somaliland and Puntland and assists Somali authorities in developing selected coastguard functions. These activities respond to a broad range of maritime threats, including piracy, human trafficking, smuggling and illegal fishing. The analysis demonstrates that maritime security in Somalia cannot be reduced to counter-piracy operations alone. It increasingly involves law enforcement, resource protection, border control and the consolidation of maritime governance.

The rule-of-law dimension is equally important. EUCAP Somalia assists with the development of legal frameworks, improves policing capacity and promotes accountability within Somali institutions. These efforts are connected with the gradual transfer of security responsibilities to national authorities. In this respect, the mission contributes not merely to immediate security but to the creation of institutions capable of assuming functions currently supported by international actors.

The article effectively structures the mission around three principal pillars. The first concerns strengthening Somali police capabilities through advice, training and equipment. The second focuses on maritime policing and coastguard functions around the principal ports of Mogadishu, Berbera and Bossaso. The third relates to the rule of law, institutional accountability and oversight within both the police and criminal-justice systems. Together, these pillars reveal a comprehensive capacity-building model in which operational effectiveness and legal legitimacy are treated as complementary objectives.

Particularly noteworthy is the emphasis upon the mission’s non-executive character. EUCAP Somalia does not replace Somali institutions or exercise ordinary policing powers on their behalf. Instead, it seeks to strengthen national and regional structures so that Somali authorities themselves can progressively assume responsibility for internal and maritime security. This principle of local ownership is fundamental to the legitimacy and sustainability of civilian capacity-building missions.

The institutional role of the European External Action Service and the Civilian Planning and Conduct Capability further clarifies the governance structure behind the mission. The CPCC provides the permanent operational headquarters for EU civilian CSDP missions, demonstrating that EUCAP Somalia forms part of an increasingly institutionalised European capacity for external civilian crisis management.

Another strength of the article is its attention to coordination with Somali planning instruments. EU support is framed within the joint EU-Somalia operational roadmap and the Somali Security Sector Development Plan, thereby seeking to align European assistance with priorities identified by Somali counterparts. This is particularly important because capacity-building initiatives risk becoming externally imposed unless they respond to domestic institutional requirements and political priorities.

The relationship between EUCAP Somalia, EUTM Somalia and Operation Atalanta is one of the most useful aspects of the study. The three missions fulfil distinct but complementary functions: EUCAP focuses on civilian capacity-building and the rule of law; EUTM contributes military training; and Operation Atalanta addresses maritime security and piracy from a naval perspective. Together they illustrate the breadth of the European Union’s Common Security and Defence Policy instruments in Somalia.

The article’s visual material reinforces this institutional complementarity. The photograph of Somali security personnel being trained by Spanish members of EUTM Somalia provides a practical illustration of the broader EU integrated approach and of the connection between military training and civilian capacity-building. The image helps demonstrate that security-sector reform depends upon coordinated development of institutions rather than the isolated strengthening of individual units.

Methodologically, the article offers a clear institutional and policy-oriented overview grounded in the relevant Council decisions, European External Action Service documentation and specialised literature. Its principal value lies in presenting the legal, organisational and operational dimensions of EUCAP Somalia within a concise framework accessible to readers interested in European security policy, maritime governance and security-sector reform.

From a broader perspective, the study illustrates the transformation of counter-piracy policy into a more comprehensive model of maritime governance. Whereas EUCAP Nestor was initially designed primarily around regional maritime-capacity development, EUCAP Somalia increasingly addresses the institutional conditions necessary for effective law enforcement: police structures, coastguard functions, legal frameworks, accountability mechanisms and cooperation between agencies. This evolution reflects a wider recognition that maritime insecurity cannot be sustainably addressed through naval presence alone.

The mission also demonstrates the relationship between security and the rule of law. Effective policing without legal accountability risks generating coercive institutions lacking legitimacy, while legal reform without operational capacity remains largely ineffective. EUCAP Somalia attempts to bridge these two dimensions by strengthening institutions while simultaneously promoting governance, transparency and oversight.

Overall, this article constitutes a useful contribution to the study of the European Union’s civilian Common Security and Defence Policy missions. José Manuel Castro Milla successfully demonstrates that EUCAP Somalia has evolved from a regional counter-piracy capacity-building initiative into a broader instrument for strengthening police institutions, maritime governance and the rule of law. The study will be of particular interest to scholars and practitioners working on EU external action, CSDP, Somalia, maritime security, security-sector reform, civilian crisis management, counter-piracy and state-building.

Abstract

This review examines José Manuel Castro Milla’s analysis of EUCAP Somalia, the European Union civilian capacity-building mission supporting security and the rule of law in Somalia. The article traces the mission’s evolution from EUCAP Nestor, established in 2012 as a regional maritime-security initiative, to its current Somalia-focused mandate. Particular attention is devoted to police capacity-building, maritime law enforcement, coastguard functions, counter-piracy, institutional accountability and the development of legal frameworks for internal security. The study also analyses the mission’s non-executive character and its coordination with EUTM Somalia, EU NAVFOR Operation Atalanta, the European External Action Service, the United Nations, the African Union and Somali authorities. It concludes that EUCAP Somalia represents an important component of the European Union’s integrated approach to security-sector reform, maritime governance and the progressive transfer of security responsibilities to Somali institutions.

Estados Unidos en Europa: ¿compromiso de verdad o repliegue disfrazado?

2026

Autoría: Serrano García, Eugenio ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 10 · Páginas: 43-47 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21642695
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Serrano García, Eugenio. “Estados Unidos en Europa: ¿compromiso de verdad o repliegue disfrazado?” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 10, August 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

Review

The future of the transatlantic relationship has become one of the central questions of contemporary security policy. Russia’s war against Ukraine, instability in the Middle East, growing strategic competition with China and renewed debate over allied burden-sharing have forced the United States to reconsider how many resources it can devote simultaneously to Europe and other theatres. In this timely article, Eugenio Serrano García examines whether Washington is genuinely preparing to reduce its commitment to Europe or whether the apparent retrenchment reflects a transformation in the manner through which American power is exercised. His central argument is persuasive: the United States is not abandoning Europe, but is seeking to preserve its military, economic and political influence while transferring a greater share of the costs and responsibilities of collective defence to its European allies.

The article begins by situating the present debate within the historical importance of Europe to American grand strategy. Since the end of the Second World War, the establishment of NATO, permanent military bases and unprecedented levels of trade and investment transformed the European continent into one of the pillars of the international order led by the United States. Serrano García nevertheless emphasises that this longstanding relationship now operates within a substantially more competitive global environment. Europe must compete for American strategic attention with the Indo-Pacific, the Middle East and other areas where Washington perceives increasingly significant challenges.

One of the article’s principal strengths lies in its distinction between rhetorical retrenchment and actual strategic withdrawal. Although the Trump administration has repeatedly invoked an “America First” logic and demanded greater European responsibility, the practical evidence analysed by the author points towards continued American engagement. Washington may seek smaller or differently distributed forces, but it continues to preserve the operational infrastructure and capabilities required to project military power into Eastern Europe, the Mediterranean and beyond. The result is not disengagement but a redefinition of participation.

The analysis of American troop deployments provides a particularly useful illustration. At the beginning of 2026, United States European Command maintained between 80,000 and 100,000 personnel in Europe, supported by a substantial network of permanent bases and additional facilities. Germany continued to function as the principal hub, followed by Italy, the United Kingdom and Spain. These installations perform functions ranging from logistics to the storage of nuclear weapons, demonstrating that American presence in Europe cannot be measured solely by troop numbers. Infrastructure itself constitutes a long-term strategic asset that enables rapid reinforcement and power projection.

Particularly important is the article’s examination of the domestic legal constraints affecting any potential American withdrawal. Serrano García shows how the 2026 National Defense Authorization Act restricts the executive branch’s ability to reduce troop levels below specified thresholds without prior consultation, justification and congressional oversight. This constitutes a significant legal dimension of the transatlantic relationship: strategic commitments are not determined solely by presidential preference but are also embedded within domestic legislative mechanisms designed to prevent abrupt unilateral changes.

The subsequent movement of forces towards Poland reinforces the author’s broader thesis. While Washington announced reductions in Germany, it simultaneously strengthened its presence on NATO’s eastern flank. This redistribution suggests that American strategy is becoming increasingly responsive to the geography of the Russian threat rather than simply reducing the overall importance of Europe. The temporary suspension of plans to remove substantial military equipment from the continent further illustrates how security conditions can rapidly override political rhetoric concerning retrenchment.

Another major contribution of the article concerns burden-sharing within NATO. Serrano García interprets the commitment made at The Hague Summit to substantially increase allied defence expenditure not as evidence of declining American interest, but as an attempt to restructure the alliance economically. Washington seeks to preserve deterrence while reducing the proportionate financial burden borne by the American taxpayer. In this sense, European rearmament is not necessarily an alternative to the transatlantic alliance; it may instead become one of the conditions for its continued functioning.

This point is especially important because the article avoids reducing NATO burden-sharing to a purely accounting exercise. Defence expenditure is connected to infrastructure, resilience, industrial capacity and the ability of European allies to assume operational responsibilities previously carried predominantly by the United States. The strategic objective is therefore not merely to spend more, but to increase Europe’s capacity to contribute meaningfully to deterrence and defence.

The study’s economic analysis further strengthens the argument against a simple narrative of American withdrawal. Serrano García demonstrates that the transatlantic economic relationship remains extraordinarily dense. Trade in goods and services, mutual foreign direct investment and the extensive integration of American and European companies continue to make the United States-European Union relationship one of the most important economic partnerships in the world. Particularly striking is the observation that American investment in the European Union substantially exceeds its investment across the Asia-Pacific region, complicating any assumption that Washington’s strategic pivot towards Asia necessarily entails economic disengagement from Europe.

The article also highlights the increasing convergence between economic and security interests. Recent trade arrangements incorporate energy purchases, defence equipment, nuclear energy and semiconductor technology, demonstrating that contemporary transatlantic relations increasingly blur the distinction between commercial policy and national security. Europe’s energy security, defence-industrial development and technological investment are becoming more closely intertwined with American economic interests.

The war in Ukraine occupies an appropriately central position in the analysis. Serrano García argues that the continuing Russian invasion makes a rapid American departure from Europe strategically difficult. A complete withdrawal of support could weaken deterrence against Russia and simultaneously affect the credibility of American security guarantees elsewhere, including the Indo-Pacific. The article therefore correctly identifies Ukraine as more than a regional conflict: it has become a test of the credibility of American alliances and of Washington’s willingness to sustain commitments when they generate prolonged financial and military costs.

The discussion of simultaneous strategic pressures is equally valuable. The United States must manage Russian aggression in Europe, conflict and instability in the Middle East and long-term competition with China. Serrano García describes the resulting approach as a form of forced alignment across several theatres. Rather than choosing completely between regions, Washington attempts to retain influence in all of them while encouraging regional allies to assume more responsibility. This provides a convincing explanation for the apparent contradiction between continued American engagement and increasingly insistent demands for European strategic autonomy.

One of the article’s most insightful distinctions concerns the difference between presence and confidence. The evidence suggests that the American military presence in Europe remains substantial, yet the predictability of the political commitment underpinning that presence has weakened. Repeated announcements, reversals, tariff threats and political disputes create uncertainty even when material capabilities remain largely intact. Consequently, the principal strategic problem for European allies may not be the immediate disappearance of American forces, but uncertainty regarding the reliability of future American decisions.

This distinction has important implications for European defence policy. Strategic autonomy can therefore develop not because Europe expects the United States necessarily to leave, but because European governments increasingly perceive excessive dependence upon an unpredictable external guarantor as a vulnerability. Greater European military capacity may thus coexist with continued American engagement rather than constituting its replacement.

The visual presentation of the article reinforces this central argument effectively. Photographs of American personnel deploying to Poland and conducting exercises on NATO’s eastern flank illustrate the continuing operational reality of the United States military presence. The final image of the Port of Rotterdam provides an equally useful counterpoint, visually emphasising that the transatlantic relationship rests not only upon military cooperation but also upon extraordinarily dense commercial and investment ties.

Methodologically, the article benefits from combining military deployments, domestic American legislation, NATO burden-sharing, trade, investment and the geopolitical consequences of the war in Ukraine. Rather than analysing the transatlantic relationship exclusively through alliance theory or military posture, Serrano García treats economic interdependence and institutional constraints as integral components of strategic commitment. This multidimensional approach provides a more convincing explanation of American behaviour than simple narratives of withdrawal or abandonment.

From a broader strategic perspective, the article points towards the emergence of what the author describes as a form of “conditional presence”. The United States seeks to retain the advantages associated with military bases, alliance leadership, European markets and strategic influence while increasingly conditioning the scale and character of its contribution upon greater European political and financial responsibility. This is not isolationism in the traditional sense. It is a renegotiation of the distribution of costs within an alliance that Washington continues to regard as relevant to its global power.

The conclusion successfully brings these different dimensions together. American troop reductions repeatedly encounter political, legal and strategic limitations; the war in Ukraine continues to require significant involvement; competition with China encourages Washington to demand greater European burden-sharing; and economic interdependence provides an additional incentive against genuine disengagement. The result is neither straightforward retreat nor unchanged continuity, but a more transactional and sometimes contradictory model of American engagement.

Overall, this article constitutes a valuable contribution to the analysis of contemporary transatlantic security. Eugenio Serrano García convincingly demonstrates that the debate should not be framed simply as a choice between American commitment and withdrawal. The more important transformation concerns the conditions under which the United States intends to remain engaged. Europe remains strategically, economically and militarily significant to Washington, but the United States increasingly expects its allies to assume a larger share of collective defence. The study will be of particular interest to scholars and practitioners working on NATO, transatlantic relations, European security, United States foreign policy, burden-sharing, strategic autonomy and contemporary geopolitics.

Abstract

This review examines Eugenio Serrano García’s analysis of the evolving United States commitment to Europe. The article argues that Washington is not undertaking a genuine strategic withdrawal from the continent but rather redefining the terms of its engagement by demanding greater European responsibility for collective defence while preserving the military infrastructure, economic ties and strategic influence necessary to remain a decisive European power. Particular attention is devoted to United States troop deployments, congressional restrictions on force reductions, NATO burden-sharing, the continuing war in Ukraine, transatlantic trade and investment, competition with China and instability in the Middle East. The study identifies an emerging model of “conditional presence” in which continued American engagement increasingly depends upon greater European financial and political contributions. It concludes that the principal risk for European security is not necessarily an immediate American withdrawal, but growing uncertainty concerning the predictability and reliability of future United States commitments.

La explotación de los recursos pesqueros del Sáhara Occidental por parte del Reino de Marruecos

2026

Autoría: Fernández González, Javier ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 10 · Páginas: 38-42 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21641818
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Fernández González, Javier. “La explotación de los recursos pesqueros del Sáhara Occidental por parte del Reino de Marruecos.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 10, August 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

Review

The exploitation of natural resources in non-self-governing and occupied territories remains one of the most contested questions at the intersection of international law, economic activity and territorial disputes. In this article, Javier Fernández González examines the particular case of fisheries in Western Sahara, focusing on the role of the Kingdom of Morocco and the legal implications arising from the exploitation of one of the most productive marine areas in the eastern Atlantic. The study combines the law of the sea, the legal status of Western Sahara, fisheries economics and international agreements in order to assess the tension between resource development and the rights of the Sahrawi people.

The article begins by establishing the geographic and economic importance of the issue. Morocco possesses extensive coastlines on both the Mediterranean Sea and the Atlantic Ocean, while its occupation and administration of Western Sahara provide access to approximately 1,100 additional kilometres of Atlantic coastline. The significance of these waters is magnified by the Canary Current and its associated upwelling system, which makes the coast of Western Sahara one of the most biologically productive marine areas in the world. This physical geography provides the essential background for understanding why fisheries have acquired such strategic economic and legal importance.

One of the article’s principal strengths lies in the connection it establishes between the exploitation of fisheries and the broader legal framework of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. Fernández González recalls that coastal States exercise sovereign rights over the exploration, exploitation, conservation and management of natural resources within their exclusive economic zones. These rights are accompanied by obligations relating to conservation and sustainable exploitation. The legal difficulty in Western Sahara arises precisely because the determination of who may legitimately exercise those rights cannot be separated from the unresolved status of the territory.

The article correctly places this problem within the continuing international status of Western Sahara as a Non-Self-Governing Territory whose process of decolonisation remains unresolved. From this perspective, Morocco’s exploitation of marine resources cannot be analysed in the same manner as the exploitation of resources unquestionably located within its internationally recognised territory. The legal regime governing natural resources must therefore be considered alongside the principles applicable to occupied or non-self-governing territories and, above all, the rights and interests of the people of Western Sahara.

A particularly valuable part of the study is its examination of the Moroccan fisheries sector itself. Fernández González demonstrates that fisheries are not a peripheral economic activity but a strategic component of Morocco’s economy, accounting for a significant share of GDP and sustaining hundreds of thousands of direct and indirect jobs. Morocco has developed a substantial fishing fleet and has become one of Africa’s principal exporters of marine products, with sardines and octopus occupying a particularly important position.

The author also situates this growth within Morocco’s broader fisheries policy. The Plan Halieutis, the development of aquaculture through the Agence Nationale pour le Développement de l’Aquaculture and the internationalisation of the sector illustrate a deliberate national strategy aimed at increasing productivity, competitiveness and sustainability. This institutional dimension is important because it demonstrates that the exploitation of fisheries in Western Sahara forms part of a much wider economic and industrial policy rather than consisting merely of local or artisanal activity.

One of the article’s most striking findings concerns the quantitative importance of Western Saharan waters to Morocco’s fisheries production. Drawing upon available data, Fernández González notes that the coastal area of Western Sahara accounted for approximately 73 per cent of Morocco’s annual coastal and artisanal catches in 2020, representing more than 63 per cent of their total national value. These figures demonstrate that Western Sahara is not economically marginal to the Moroccan fisheries industry; on the contrary, its marine resources constitute one of the structural foundations of the sector.

The discussion of aquaculture further strengthens this analysis. The article shows how the exploitation of natural fishing grounds is increasingly complemented by the development of aquaculture facilities, especially around Dakhla and Oued Ed-Dahab. Oyster, mussel, clam and scallop cultivation, together with marine cages for species such as sea bream and sea bass, illustrates the diversification and long-term consolidation of the sector. The concentration of a substantial proportion of Morocco’s aquaculture facilities in Western Sahara adds a further dimension to the legal debate because it involves not only harvesting naturally occurring resources but also creating permanent productive infrastructures linked to the territory.

The analysis of the fisheries agreements between the European Union and Morocco constitutes one of the central legal sections of the article. Fernández González traces the evolution of bilateral arrangements from the 1988 agreement between the European Economic Community and Morocco through later agreements and protocols adopted in 1992, 2006, 2013 and 2019. Particularly important is the fact that earlier agreements avoided explicit reference to Western Sahara while nevertheless permitting European vessels to operate in waters adjacent to the territory.

This ambiguity gradually became legally untenable. The 2019 Sustainable Fisheries Partnership Agreement expressly acknowledged that Western Sahara remained listed by the United Nations as a Non-Self-Governing Territory while simultaneously extending the geographical scope of fishing activities to waters adjacent to the territory. The resulting contradiction between non-recognition of Moroccan sovereignty and practical inclusion of Western Saharan waters lies at the heart of the legal controversy examined by the author.

Particularly significant is the discussion of the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union. Fernández González highlights the Court’s conclusion that agreements affecting Western Sahara could not lawfully be applied without the consent of the Sahrawi people. The judicial emphasis upon consent and the requirement that exploitation generate tangible and proportionate benefits for the population provides the key legal counterweight to the economic integration of the territory into Moroccan fisheries policy.

The article also broadens the analysis beyond the European Union by examining Morocco’s fisheries cooperation with third States. Agreements with Japan and several West African countries, together with more recent arrangements involving China and Russia, demonstrate the increasingly international character of Morocco’s fisheries policy. Yet the author identifies a recurring difficulty: many of these agreements make no explicit distinction between internationally recognised Moroccan waters and those adjacent to Western Sahara. As a result, activities formally authorised within Moroccan fisheries cooperation may in practice extend into waters whose legal status remains disputed.

The role of multinational companies adds another relevant dimension. The presence of foreign firms in aquaculture, processing and export demonstrates that the legal controversy surrounding Western Sahara’s marine resources extends beyond intergovernmental agreements. Private economic actors may also participate in activities connected with the exploitation and commercialisation of resources originating in the territory, thereby raising broader questions concerning due diligence, corporate responsibility and the identification of the beneficiaries of economic development.

The article’s visual material effectively supports its argument. The photograph of the fish market in Dakhla illustrates the direct relationship between local economic activity and the richness of Western Saharan fishing grounds, while the image of the port of Agadir shows the industrial scale and infrastructure supporting Morocco’s broader fisheries economy. Most valuable, however, is the geopolitical map showing Western Sahara, the deployment of MINURSO and areas associated with resource exploration. It visually connects the fisheries question with the unresolved territorial dispute and demonstrates that natural-resource exploitation cannot be detached from the geopolitical status of the territory.

Methodologically, the study benefits from combining legal analysis with economic and sectoral data. Rather than treating the fisheries dispute solely as a question of territorial sovereignty, Fernández González demonstrates how legal principles operate within a complex system of production, employment, infrastructure, international agreements, private investment and environmental sustainability. This interdisciplinary approach makes the article particularly useful for understanding the practical consequences of the unresolved status of Western Sahara.

From a broader perspective, the article illustrates a fundamental problem in contemporary international law: economic integration can gradually produce material effects that resemble the consolidation of sovereignty even where sovereignty itself remains legally disputed. Ports, aquaculture facilities, industrial processing, foreign investment and international fisheries agreements may deepen the economic incorporation of a territory without resolving its international legal status. The case of Western Sahara therefore highlights the importance of maintaining a clear distinction between effective administration and lawful title.

The environmental dimension should also be emphasised. The exceptional productivity of the Canary Current creates substantial economic opportunities, but the growing scale of industrial fishing and aquaculture simultaneously increases the need for effective conservation and sustainability measures. Fernández González therefore correctly concludes that any lawful system of exploitation must address not only the rights of the Sahrawi people but also the risk of overexploitation of the marine resources upon which the long-term economic value of the territory depends.

Overall, this article constitutes a useful and timely contribution to the study of natural-resource exploitation in Western Sahara. Javier Fernández González successfully demonstrates that the fisheries question lies at the intersection of the law of the sea, decolonisation, territorial status, economic development and international cooperation. The study’s principal value lies in showing the extraordinary economic importance of Western Saharan waters to Morocco while simultaneously underlining that effective exploitation cannot by itself resolve the underlying legal question. The future legitimacy of fisheries activity in the territory ultimately depends upon sustainable management, respect for the legal status of Western Sahara and effective protection of the rights and interests of the Sahrawi people.

Abstract

This review examines Javier Fernández González’s analysis of the exploitation of fisheries resources in Western Sahara by the Kingdom of Morocco. The article combines the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, the unresolved legal status of Western Sahara, the economic importance of Morocco’s fisheries sector and the evolution of international fisheries agreements. Particular attention is devoted to the exceptional biological productivity of Western Saharan waters, the development of aquaculture around Dakhla, the economic dependence of Morocco’s fisheries industry upon catches originating in the territory and the fisheries agreements concluded between Morocco and the European Union. The study also considers the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union concerning the consent of the Sahrawi people and examines Morocco’s fisheries cooperation with third States and international companies. It concludes that the exploitation of Western Sahara’s marine resources must combine sustainable management with effective protection of the rights and interests of the Sahrawi people.

Jueces y funcionarios públicos bajo ocupación beligerante: el alcance del artículo 54 del IV CG

2026

Autoría: Cosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 10 · Páginas: 8-37 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21641459
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Cosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel. “Jueces y funcionarios públicos bajo ocupación beligerante: el alcance del artículo 54 del IV CG.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 10, August 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

Review

The administration of occupied territory poses one of the most persistent structural dilemmas of the law of belligerent occupation. An Occupying Power must preserve public order and ensure the functioning of essential institutions, yet it cannot treat temporary authority as sovereignty or transform the local administration into an instrument of its own political project. In this extensive and carefully constructed study, Andrés Miguel Cosialls Ubach examines this tension through Article 54 of the Fourth Geneva Convention, focusing specifically on the legal position of judges and public officials under occupation. The central thesis is clear: Article 54 does not establish absolute security of tenure, but neither does it grant the Occupying Power an unrestricted power of dismissal. Removal must remain functional, temporary and individualised, and must comply with necessity, proportionality, non-discrimination, reversibility and appropriate control.

One of the article’s most important contributions lies in identifying Article 54 as a rule against what may be described as institutional capture. Judges, police officers, municipal authorities, civil registrars, technical personnel and other public servants constitute the institutional infrastructure through which everyday life continues during occupation. Their protection is therefore not merely a matter of individual employment status. The destruction or political appropriation of the local civil service may undermine the Occupying Power’s own obligation to maintain public life and protect the civilian population. Cosialls Ubach consequently places institutional continuity at the centre of the provision’s normative purpose.

Particularly persuasive is the systematic interpretation of Article 54 alongside Article 43 of the Hague Regulations and Articles 47 and 64 of the Fourth Geneva Convention. The author rejects an isolated reading of the Occupying Power’s authority to remove public officials. Instead, the provision must be understood within a broader legal structure based upon the non-transfer of sovereignty, continuity of existing institutions and preservation of the pre-occupation legal order. The Occupying Power possesses effective authority because it controls the territory, but that factual authority does not extinguish the sovereignty of the displaced State or transform local officials into servants of the foreign power.

This distinction between effective obedience and political allegiance represents one of the conceptual strengths of the article. Public officials may be required to comply with lawful administrative instructions necessary to preserve public life, while continuing to owe allegiance to the displaced sovereign. Cosialls Ubach formulates this intermediate legal position with considerable precision: occupation permits functional obedience without political adhesion and continuity of public service without a rupture of the pre-existing legal relationship with the occupied State. This interpretation gives practical meaning to Article 54’s prohibition on coercion and discrimination against officials who abstain from carrying out their functions for reasons of conscience.

The article’s treatment of temporariness and reversibility is equally significant. Belligerent occupation is by definition provisional, even where it continues for a prolonged period. Measures affecting the administration must therefore remain capable, as far as possible, of subsequent revision by the restored sovereign. Temporary reassignment, suspension or interim appointments may satisfy this requirement, whereas the wholesale destruction of professional structures, permanent transfer of competences or mass replacement of personnel may predetermine the institutional future of the occupied State. The author convincingly demonstrates that personnel policy is therefore capable of producing effects far beyond individual employment decisions: it may alter the legal culture and administrative capacity of the State for decades.

A further strength of the study is its reconstruction of the historical origins of Article 54. Cosialls Ubach recalls that the provision was not contained in the original ICRC draft and was introduced during the 1949 Diplomatic Conference at the suggestion of the Belgian delegation. Its emergence was closely connected with the European experience of occupation during the Second World War, when occupying authorities sought to pressure judges and officials into supporting their policies, abandoning loyalty to legitimate governments or performing functions incompatible with their previous institutional duties. The historical genealogy of the provision therefore confirms that Article 54 was designed not only to protect individuals from direct punishment but also to prevent administrative structures from being gradually converted into instruments of foreign political authority.

Especially valuable is the author’s identification of the three complementary purposes underlying the rule. Article 54 performs an institutional function by preserving the continuity of administration and justice; a personal function by protecting office-holders against intimidation, coercion and retaliation; and a political-legal function by preventing the Occupying Power from using local institutions to simulate a transfer of sovereignty or legitimise the new authority. This tripartite construction provides a particularly useful analytical framework for understanding why the provision protects the status of officials while nevertheless permitting removal in certain circumstances.

The discussion of the personal scope of Article 54 is similarly nuanced. Rather than adopting an excessively formal conception of “public official”, the study proposes a functional approach based upon the nature of the activity performed, the person’s integration into public structures and the responsibility exercised on behalf of the community. This allows the provision to encompass not only central government officials but also municipal personnel, civil registrars, tax officials, technical staff, public hospitals and schools, transport authorities, public undertakings and elected local officials where they exercise genuinely public functions. The analysis is especially relevant to contemporary administrations, where functions historically performed directly by the State may have been outsourced or entrusted to hybrid public entities.

Judicial independence receives appropriately heightened protection within the article. Cosialls Ubach demonstrates that altering the “status” of a judge cannot be reduced to formal dismissal or reduction in rank. It may include changes to jurisdiction, disciplinary guarantees, access to files, security, promotion, working conditions or case allocation where these are designed to influence judicial decisions. Likewise, transfer to a nominal tribunal lacking genuine competence or the selective removal of sensitive cases may constitute an unlawful alteration of judicial status. This functional understanding significantly strengthens the protection offered by Article 54 and connects the law of occupation with the broader requirement of an independent administration of justice.

The treatment of freedom of conscience constitutes another of the article’s most original elements. The author rejects a narrow understanding confined to religious or philosophical belief. Reasons of conscience may arise from professional ethics, fidelity to the constitutional order, refusal to participate in violations of humanitarian law or objection to exercising public powers in the name of a foreign authority. Importantly, the protected response need not always consist of complete resignation. It may also involve refusal to perform a particular act, recusal from a specific matter or transfer to neutral functions. The author therefore proposes a graduated approach in which permanent removal should be reserved for situations where the objection substantially prevents performance of the office and no less restrictive alternative remains available.

This interpretation is complemented by a careful distinction between remaining in public office and being required to perform limited forms of compulsory work under Article 51. An official may resign from a position whose institutional significance creates an unacceptable conflict of conscience and yet remain liable, under strictly defined conditions, to perform a necessary technical task for the benefit of the population. The example of an engineer responsible for essential sanitation infrastructure illustrates the point effectively. By contrast, judicial decision-making cannot simply be requisitioned as compulsory labour because adjudication necessarily depends upon independence and conscience.

The power of removal is consequently subjected to a demanding legal framework. Cosialls Ubach argues that dismissal cannot be treated as an attribute of sovereign discretion. It requires legitimate purpose, necessity, individual assessment, proportionality, temporariness, procedural safeguards and consideration of the effects upon institutional continuity. Particularly important is the procedural dimension: notification of reasons, the possibility of responding, preservation of records and some form of independent review become essential safeguards against arbitrary or politically motivated dismissals. Before removing large numbers of officials, the Occupying Power must also evaluate whether the services for which it remains responsible can continue functioning.

The article is also notable for recognising that discrimination and coercion frequently operate through indirect administrative techniques rather than explicit criminal punishment. Loss of promotion opportunities, denial of housing, pension restrictions, adverse security classifications or discriminatory transfers may function as concealed reprisals against officials who invoke conscience or refuse political collaboration. This broader perspective is indispensable to an effective reading of Article 54, since institutional capture can occur incrementally through employment decisions that appear neutral when examined individually.

A further important contribution is the connection established between violations of Article 54 and broader questions of international responsibility. The author notes that the provision does not itself transform every unlawful dismissal into an international crime. Nevertheless, systematic persecution of judges or public officials on political, national, ethnic or religious grounds may contribute to crimes against humanity where the relevant contextual elements are present. Arbitrary detention, deportation or disappearance of members of the judiciary may also generate individual criminal responsibility, while mass dismissals can constitute evidence of unlawful institutional transformation or de facto annexation.

The analysis is particularly effective in demonstrating why collective purges are difficult to reconcile with the underlying logic of occupation law. An Occupying Power may legitimately remove an individual who presents a concrete security risk, has participated in serious crimes or cannot perform the required function. What Article 54 resists is the conversion of such individualised powers into categorical exclusion based upon previous affiliation, nationality, political identity or mere membership in the former administration. Institutional reform therefore does not eliminate the obligation to preserve local capacity or dispense with individual assessment.

The visual dimension of the article reinforces this argument particularly well. Images of Iraqi judges, police officers, health personnel, engineers and public infrastructure demonstrate that administration under occupation is not an abstract bureaucratic concern. The photograph of Chief Investigative Judge Ra’id Juhi emphasises the particular vulnerability of judicial independence, while the images of Iraqi police and technical personnel illustrate how maintaining local institutional capacity is inseparable from the Occupying Power’s obligation to preserve public life.

Methodologically, the article combines close treaty interpretation, the ICRC Commentary, leading contemporary scholarship on occupation law and the practical consequences of institutional decision-making. Its principal merit lies in moving beyond a literal reading of the final sentence of Article 54 and reconstructing the provision as part of the internal logic of the law of occupation. The resulting framework is both doctrinally coherent and operationally useful.

From a broader perspective, the study contributes to one of the central debates surrounding modern occupations: how far an Occupying Power may reform dysfunctional or abusive institutions without crossing the line from temporary administration into sovereign transformation. Cosialls Ubach does not argue for institutional immobility. Necessary reforms remain possible, particularly where required to protect fundamental rights or ensure essential services, but they must satisfy a cumulative test based upon genuine necessity, connection with the occupier’s legal obligations, proportionality, temporariness, minimal alteration and benefit to the population.

Overall, this article constitutes a substantial contribution to the contemporary law of belligerent occupation. Andrés Miguel Cosialls Ubach convincingly demonstrates that Article 54 of the Fourth Geneva Convention should be understood as a mechanism for preserving institutional continuity without permitting institutional appropriation. Its underlying logic can be summarised through four particularly effective propositions developed in the conclusion: continuity without appropriation, legal obedience without political allegiance, replacement without punishment, and reform without sovereign transformation. This functional and protective interpretation offers a coherent framework for reconciling administrative necessity, judicial independence, individual conscience and the provisional character of occupation.

Abstract

This review examines Andrés Miguel Cosialls Ubach’s analysis of Article 54 of the Fourth Geneva Convention and the legal status of judges and public officials under belligerent occupation. The article argues that the provision neither guarantees absolute security of tenure nor grants the Occupying Power unrestricted authority to dismiss local officials. Instead, removal must be understood as a functional and exceptional power subject to necessity, proportionality, individual assessment, non-discrimination, temporariness, reversibility and procedural control. Through a systematic interpretation of Article 54 alongside Article 43 of the Hague Regulations and Articles 47, 51 and 64 of the Fourth Geneva Convention, the study develops a broader theory of institutional continuity under occupation. Particular attention is devoted to judicial independence, freedom of conscience, compulsory labour, loyalty to the displaced sovereign, public-service continuity and the prohibition of politically motivated institutional transformation. The article concludes that the law of occupation requires continuity without appropriation, legal obedience without political allegiance, replacement without punishment and reform without sovereign transformation.

La Agenda WPS y los Planes de Acción Nacional sobre Mujeres, Paz y Seguridad

2026

Autoría: Brox Sáenz de la Calzada, Alicia ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 10 · Páginas: 1,6-7 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21641218
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Brox Sáenz de la Calzada, Alicia. “La Agenda WPS y los Planes de Acción Nacional sobre Mujeres, Paz y Seguridad.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 10, August 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

Review

Few developments within contemporary international peace and security policy have been as significant as the consolidation of the Women, Peace and Security Agenda. Since the adoption of United Nations Security Council Resolution 1325 in 2000, the relationship between gender equality, conflict prevention, peacebuilding and the protection of women in armed conflict has gradually evolved from a largely declaratory commitment into an increasingly structured policy framework. In this concise and highly topical article, Alicia Brox Sáenz de la Calzada examines the development of the Women, Peace and Security Agenda and its implementation through National Action Plans, with particular attention to Spain’s Third National Action Plan for Women, Peace and Security for the period 2025–2030.

The article begins by recalling the importance of Resolution 1325/2000 as a turning point in the international recognition of the relationship between the achievement of sustainable peace and the effective participation of women in peace negotiations, conflict resolution and security policy. The Women, Peace and Security Agenda is presented not merely as a political programme, but as an international framework intended to translate commitments undertaken at the multilateral level into concrete national policies. This institutional perspective is particularly valuable because it highlights the transition from normative recognition to implementation through domestic planning instruments.

One of the article’s principal strengths lies in its clear explanation of the four traditional pillars of the WPS Agenda. Brox Sáenz de la Calzada identifies participation, protection, prevention, and relief and recovery as the essential dimensions around which national implementation must be organised. Women’s participation in decision-making processes is therefore placed alongside their protection from gender-based and sexual violence, the prevention of conflict-related abuses through gender-sensitive security policies, and the incorporation of women’s and girls’ specific needs into humanitarian assistance and post-conflict reconstruction. This structure provides the reader with a concise yet coherent understanding of the architecture of the WPS framework.

Particularly relevant is the transition from this general international framework to the Spanish case. The author notes that Spain was among the early adopters of a National Action Plan and currently implements its Third National Action Plan for Women, Peace and Security, covering the period 2025–2030. Unlike previous plans, the new instrument is described as more operational than programmatic, introducing revised objectives and mechanisms intended to facilitate the assessment of implementation and effectiveness. This shift is significant because one of the recurring challenges of National Action Plans has been the gap between political commitment and measurable implementation.

The article also draws attention to the broader conceptual principles underlying the Spanish plan. Human rights, intersectionality and intergenerational perspectives are combined with a whole-of-government approach intended to transform the WPS Agenda into a genuine State policy. Brox Sáenz de la Calzada correctly situates this development within a rapidly changing international environment characterised by increasingly complex economic and sociocultural dynamics, growing multipolarity and the destabilising effects associated with climate change. The WPS Agenda is therefore presented not as an isolated gender policy, but as part of a wider response to contemporary patterns of insecurity.

The first major line of action examined concerns conflict prevention and women’s participation in fragile environments. The Spanish plan links peace and security to access to inclusive education, social and health services, sexual and reproductive rights, women’s economic autonomy and female leadership. This approach is particularly significant because it broadens the conventional understanding of security. Conflict prevention is not reduced to diplomatic or military action but is connected with the social, institutional and economic conditions that make communities more resilient and less vulnerable to instability.

Equally important is the article’s analysis of women’s participation in peace and security decision-making. The Third National Action Plan places particular emphasis on full, equal, safe and meaningful participation, while incorporating the digital dimension into the WPS framework. Brox Sáenz de la Calzada highlights the growing relevance of digital violence and the need for prevention, awareness and training mechanisms capable of protecting women’s participation in increasingly digitised political and security environments. This is one of the most contemporary dimensions of the plan, demonstrating how the WPS Agenda is adapting to forms of vulnerability that were far less prominent when Resolution 1325 was originally adopted.

The article further examines Spain’s commitment to strengthening the protection of women’s rights through international legal and institutional instruments. Particularly noteworthy is the reference to General Recommendation No. 40 of the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women and its connection with Spain’s feminist foreign policy. This reinforces the idea that the WPS Agenda operates at the intersection of international human rights law, foreign policy and security policy, rather than within a single isolated institutional domain.

Another substantial part of the study concerns the protection of women during armed conflict, especially against conflict-related sexual violence. The author highlights Spanish commitments to support the work of the United Nations Special Representative of the Secretary-General on Sexual Violence in Conflict and to strengthen judicial accountability through initiatives such as the United Kingdom’s Preventing Sexual Violence in Conflict Initiative. This aspect of the plan is particularly important because it connects victim protection with accountability mechanisms, thereby reinforcing the legal dimension of the WPS Agenda.

The discussion of humanitarian action and post-conflict recovery further expands the scope of the analysis. Brox Sáenz de la Calzada explains how the Spanish plan seeks to integrate gender equality and the empowerment of women and girls into humanitarian response, development cooperation and peacebuilding. Particularly significant is the reference to the humanitarian-development-peace nexus, which reflects a broader international trend towards overcoming institutional fragmentation between emergency assistance, long-term development and conflict prevention.

The final dimension examined concerns the institutionalisation of the WPS Agenda across public administration. The Third National Action Plan reinforces training for personnel of the General State Administration in areas including structural inequalities, gender perspectives, gender-sensitive conflict analysis and democratic memory. This institutional component is essential because effective implementation ultimately depends upon administrative capacity. The article therefore demonstrates that the WPS Agenda cannot remain confined to diplomatic declarations: it must become embedded within the structures, procedures and professional training of the institutions responsible for foreign, defence, security and cooperation policies.

The visual presentation of the article also reinforces its central message. The photographs illustrating multinational Women, Peace and Security activities involving military personnel from several countries provide a practical representation of the Agenda’s international and operational dimension. The image of the Sea Sisters activity in Djibouti is especially effective in showing how gender integration and international cooperation are increasingly incorporated into security-sector engagement and military partnership programmes.

Methodologically, the article adopts a concise institutional and legal-policy approach. Rather than attempting to provide an exhaustive historical examination of Resolution 1325 and the broader WPS normative framework, Brox Sáenz de la Calzada focuses on the practical implementation of the Agenda through Spain’s current National Action Plan. This choice gives the study considerable contemporary relevance and makes it particularly useful for readers interested in the translation of international commitments into national public policy.

From a broader perspective, the article demonstrates how the Women, Peace and Security Agenda has evolved beyond its original focus on women’s participation and protection in armed conflict. The Third Spanish National Action Plan incorporates questions of digital violence, intersectionality, climate-related insecurity, humanitarian-development-peace coordination and institutional training. The result is an increasingly comprehensive conception of security in which gender equality becomes part of conflict prevention, crisis management, post-conflict recovery and long-term institutional resilience.

Overall, this article constitutes a clear and timely contribution to the study of the Women, Peace and Security Agenda and its implementation within Spanish foreign and security policy. Alicia Brox Sáenz de la Calzada successfully demonstrates how National Action Plans operate as essential mechanisms for translating the principles of Resolution 1325 into concrete governmental commitments. The study will be of particular interest to scholars and practitioners working in international law, human rights, peace and security studies, gender studies, defence policy, humanitarian action and international cooperation.

Abstract

This review examines Alicia Brox Sáenz de la Calzada’s analysis of the Women, Peace and Security Agenda and its implementation through National Action Plans, with particular attention to Spain’s Third National Action Plan for Women, Peace and Security 2025–2030. The article explains the four traditional pillars of the WPS Agenda—participation, protection, prevention, and relief and recovery—and analyses how Spain has incorporated these principles into a more operational policy framework. Particular attention is devoted to women’s participation in peace and security decision-making, conflict prevention, digital violence, conflict-related sexual violence, humanitarian action, the humanitarian-development-peace nexus and the institutionalisation of gender-sensitive approaches within public administration. The study demonstrates that the WPS Agenda has progressively evolved into a comprehensive framework linking gender equality, human rights, security policy, foreign policy and peacebuilding.

Análisis técnico-jurídico de las posibilidades de la Artillería Antiaérea ante la Amenaza de los sUAS

2026

Autoría: Castro Milla, José Manuel ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 10 · Páginas: 1-5 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21640787
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Castro Milla, José Manuel. “Análisis técnico-jurídico de las posibilidades de la Artillería Antiaérea ante la Amenaza de los sUAS.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 10, August 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

Review

Few technological developments have transformed contemporary military operations as rapidly as the proliferation of small unmanned aerial systems (sUAS). Once largely confined to technologically advanced armed forces, unmanned aerial capabilities have become increasingly accessible to state and non-state actors alike, profoundly altering the relationship between offensive capability, defensive preparedness and technological superiority. In this timely and highly relevant article, José Manuel Castro Milla examines the technical and legal challenges posed by sUAS to modern Air Defence Artillery, arguing that traditional air-defence architectures must evolve towards integrated, multidomain and increasingly automated counter-UAS systems capable of responding to threats characterised by low cost, reduced signatures and extremely short decision cycles.

The article begins by placing the problem within the broader transformation of Force Protection. Rather than approaching the defence of military installations as a static or essentially logistical function, Castro Milla presents it as an increasingly strategic requirement directly connected with operational freedom of action. Particularly effective is the use of Alan Vick’s Snakes in the Eagle’s Nest as an analytical framework: the protected military base becomes the “nest”, while the emerging asymmetric threat constitutes the “snake” capable of circumventing conventional defensive advantages. The metaphor successfully illustrates how inexpensive and commercially available technologies can challenge sophisticated military systems and force established air-defence structures to reconsider their assumptions.

One of the article’s principal strengths lies in its examination of the so-called “Second Drone Age”. Castro Milla identifies the proliferation of Low, Slow and Small systems as a fundamental disruption of traditional air-defence models. Reduced radar cross-section, limited infrared and acoustic signatures and unconventional flight profiles allow many small drones to operate precisely within the technological gaps of systems originally designed to detect and intercept larger, faster and more predictable aerial targets. The author further emphasises how artificial intelligence, autonomous swarm coordination, fifth-generation communications and beyond-line-of-sight connectivity are expanding the operational potential of these systems.

The discussion of technological asymmetry is particularly convincing. The article correctly highlights that the significance of sUAS does not derive solely from their technical sophistication, but from the disproportion between their acquisition cost and the value of the military assets they can threaten. The 2018 attacks against the Russian bases of Khmeimim and Tartus provide a useful illustration of this phenomenon: relatively rudimentary unmanned platforms were capable of creating a significant defensive challenge for forces equipped with advanced air-defence systems. The case demonstrates one of the defining characteristics of contemporary warfare: technological effectiveness increasingly depends not simply upon possessing the most expensive system, but upon exploiting vulnerabilities within the adversary’s defensive architecture.

Castro Milla’s analysis of the necessary response is equally valuable. Rather than proposing a single technological solution, the article advocates a genuine “system of systems” integrating detection, tracking, command and control, data fusion and multiple categories of effectors. Active radar sensors must operate alongside passive radio-frequency, acoustic and electro-optical/infrared systems, while the resulting information must be fused into a coherent low-altitude operational picture. This layered approach reflects the essential difficulty of the counter-UAS mission: no individual sensor or weapon can adequately address the full spectrum of small unmanned threats.

Particularly significant is the article’s treatment of automation and human control. Saturation attacks involving numerous simultaneous targets compress the decision-making process to such an extent that conventional human-in-the-loop models may become operationally insufficient. Castro Milla therefore examines the transition towards human-on-the-loop architectures, in which automated systems identify, classify and prioritise threats while retaining human supervision over the ultimate use of force. This is one of the article’s most important contributions because it directly connects technological development with the legal and ethical problem of human control over increasingly autonomous military systems. The challenge is no longer simply how rapidly a defensive system can react, but how legal responsibility and operational supervision can be preserved when machine-speed decision-making becomes indispensable.

The examination of directed-energy weapons further reinforces the forward-looking character of the study. High-Energy Lasers and High-Power Microwave systems are presented as particularly promising countermeasures against sUAS, especially where conventional interception would impose an unsustainable economic or logistical burden. Their virtually negligible cost per engagement, rapid response and potential for repeated use make them attractive against massed drone attacks and loitering munitions. High-power microwave systems are especially relevant in this context because their effects may extend across multiple electronic targets simultaneously, offering an important response to the problem of autonomous swarms.

Nevertheless, the article does not fall into technological determinism. Castro Milla appropriately recognises the limitations affecting directed-energy systems, including atmospheric interference, substantial energy requirements and the broader operational conditions governing their effectiveness. The discussion of loitering munitions is especially useful because these systems create what may be described as a persistent threat window: unlike conventional missiles, they can remain within an operational area while awaiting an appropriate target. Defensive systems must therefore combine rapid reaction with persistence and economic sustainability, precisely the characteristics that directed-energy weapons may increasingly provide.

The legal dimension constitutes another major strength of the study. Castro Milla correctly distinguishes between counter-UAS operations conducted within national territory during peacetime and those undertaken in the context of armed conflict. The applicable rules concerning the use of force, hostile intent, competence and rules of engagement differ substantially between these environments. Within the Spanish framework, the author additionally stresses the importance of coordination between the Armed Forces and the State Security Forces and Corps, together with the integration of military and civilian airspace-management capabilities. This institutional perspective substantially enriches what might otherwise have remained an exclusively technical analysis.

Particularly noteworthy is the connection established between counter-UAS technologies and the principles governing the conduct of hostilities. The author argues that non-kinetic effectors and directed-energy systems may contribute to compliance with the principles of distinction and proportionality by reducing the collateral risks associated with conventional kinetic interception, particularly in urban environments or around critical infrastructure. This observation is highly relevant for contemporary military operations, where the effectiveness of an air-defence response must increasingly be assessed not merely in terms of whether a hostile platform can be neutralised, but also according to the consequences generated by the chosen method of interception.

The conclusions successfully translate the preceding analysis into practical doctrinal recommendations. Castro Milla advocates the consolidation of integrated surveillance, control and coordination capabilities for the lowest layers of the airspace, the development of AI-assisted command-and-control systems operating under supervised autonomy and a renewed emphasis upon passive defence, multispectral concealment, deception and resilience. Particularly valuable is this final insistence upon passive protection. Counter-UAS defence cannot depend exclusively upon detecting and destroying hostile platforms; it must also reduce the enemy’s capacity to identify, classify and successfully engage valuable targets.

Methodologically, the article succeeds in combining operational analysis, emerging military technology, air-defence doctrine and legal reasoning within a compact and coherent framework. Its interdisciplinary character is especially appropriate to the counter-UAS problem, which cannot adequately be understood through a purely technological or purely legal perspective. Sensors, effectors, artificial intelligence, command structures, rules of engagement and legal constraints increasingly form parts of the same operational architecture.

The visual dimension of the article also reinforces its argument. The photographs of systems such as M-LIDS and the Stryker DE M-SHORAD illustrate the transition from theoretical counter-UAS concepts towards deployable integrated solutions. Particularly significant is the latter system, which demonstrates the growing effort to incorporate high-energy directed-energy weapons into mobile short-range air-defence platforms, visually encapsulating the technological transformation discussed throughout the article.

From a broader strategic perspective, the study highlights a fundamental transformation in the economics of air defence. Armed forces can no longer assume that technological superiority will automatically translate into defensive superiority when adversaries are capable of employing numerous inexpensive systems to saturate costly defensive architectures. The resulting challenge requires a combination of technological adaptation, organisational integration, doctrinal innovation and legal preparedness.

Overall, this article constitutes a valuable and timely contribution to the study of contemporary Air Defence Artillery and counter-UAS operations. José Manuel Castro Milla successfully demonstrates that the challenge posed by small unmanned aerial systems extends far beyond the acquisition of new weapons. It requires a comprehensive transformation of detection systems, command-and-control architectures, defensive effectors, human-machine interaction and the legal frameworks governing the use of force. The study will be of particular interest to specialists in air defence, counter-UAS operations, emerging military technologies, defence policy, operational law and International Humanitarian Law seeking to understand how rapidly evolving unmanned threats are reshaping the defence of forces and critical infrastructure.

Abstract

This review examines José Manuel Castro Milla’s technical and legal analysis of the challenges posed by small unmanned aerial systems (sUAS) to contemporary Air Defence Artillery. The article situates the proliferation of Low, Slow and Small platforms within the “Second Drone Age” and argues that conventional air-defence architectures must evolve towards integrated counter-UAS systems combining active and passive sensors, artificial intelligence, command-and-control networks and both kinetic and non-kinetic effectors. Particular attention is devoted to supervised autonomy, directed-energy weapons, electronic warfare and the growing challenge of drone swarms and loitering munitions. The study also addresses the legal framework governing counter-UAS operations, including rules of engagement, hostile intent, civil-military coordination and the principles of distinction and proportionality. It concludes that effective defence against emerging unmanned threats requires not only technological innovation but also doctrinal adaptation, institutional integration, passive resilience and a robust legal framework capable of reconciling operational speed with human supervision and the lawful use of force.

Si vis pacem, para bellum: Flavio Vegecio y los fundamentos filosófico-jurídicos de la Defensa

2026

Autoría: Cosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 9 · Páginas: 81 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21238671
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Cosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel. “Si vis pacem, para bellum: Flavio Vegecio y los fundamentos filosófico-jurídicos de la Defensa.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 9, June 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

Review

Few maxims have exercised such enduring influence over Western strategic thought as Si vis pacem, para bellum—“If you desire peace, prepare for war.” Frequently invoked in political discourse, military doctrine and public debate, the phrase is often interpreted as a celebration of militarism or an endorsement of armed conflict. In this concise yet intellectually rich article, Andrés Miguel Cosialls Ubach challenges this widespread misconception by returning to its original author, Flavius Vegetius Renatus, and examining the philosophical and legal foundations underlying one of the most influential principles in the history of defence theory. Rather than advocating war, the author demonstrates that Vegetius regarded military preparedness as an indispensable condition for preserving peace, political order and the rule of law.

The article begins by situating Vegetius within the historical context of the declining Roman Empire during the late fourth and early fifth centuries AD. At a time when Rome faced increasing pressure from external enemies and the progressive deterioration of military discipline, Vegetius did not advocate imperial expansion or aggressive warfare. Instead, his principal concern was the preservation of political stability through institutional preparedness. According to the author, the deterioration of military capability inevitably undermined political authority itself, demonstrating that peace cannot survive where the institutions responsible for its defence are neglected. This historical reconstruction effectively dispels the common misunderstanding that Si vis pacem, para bellum constitutes a doctrine of militarisation rather than one of strategic prevention.

One of the article's principal strengths lies in its philosophical interpretation of peace. Cosialls Ubach argues that Vegetius rejected any conception of peace as a spontaneous or natural condition of human society. Instead, peace is presented as an institutional achievement requiring continuous preparation, organisation and vigilance. Security cannot be improvised once threats have already materialised. This understanding anticipates many principles that continue to shape modern theories of national security, strategic planning and defence policy. The author successfully demonstrates that, despite having been formulated more than fifteen centuries ago, Vegetius' reasoning retains remarkable contemporary relevance.

Particularly valuable is the discussion concerning the relationship between force and law. Although Vegetius was not himself a jurist, the article convincingly argues that he understood one of the fundamental truths underlying every legal order: law requires institutions capable of guaranteeing its effective implementation. Rights, justice, public administration, property and individual liberty ultimately depend upon the existence of security. Consequently, military defence is not presented as an end in itself but rather as an instrument whose ultimate purpose is the protection of civil society and constitutional order. This interpretation provides one of the article's most important contributions by linking classical military thought directly with contemporary legal philosophy.

The comparison with Thomas Hobbes further strengthens the analysis. The author demonstrates how Vegetius anticipated central elements of Hobbes' political philosophy, particularly the proposition that political authority exists primarily to prevent the insecurity characteristic of the state of nature. Both thinkers recognise that peace depends upon the existence of a legitimate force capable of deterring those willing to undermine public order. While separated by more than a millennium, Vegetius and Hobbes converge upon the same essential conclusion: security constitutes the indispensable precondition for every functioning legal system. This comparative perspective significantly enriches the article's philosophical dimension.

The article also explores Vegetius' influence upon the later development of just war theory. Although Vegetius never formulated a complete moral doctrine governing armed conflict, Cosialls Ubach explains how his conception of military preparedness proved fully compatible with the subsequent reflections of Saint Augustine and Thomas Aquinas. Both thinkers justified war only when undertaken to restore justice or protect the political community against unjust aggression. Within this framework, military preparation acquires a clear ethical justification: maintaining adequate defensive capabilities does not imply a desire for war but rather ensures the capacity to preserve peace whenever it comes under threat. This discussion successfully integrates classical military thought into the broader evolution of Christian political philosophy and International Humanitarian Law.

Equally compelling is the examination of Niccolò Machiavelli's intellectual debt to Vegetius. In The Prince and The Art of War, Machiavelli similarly argued that political independence requires autonomous military capacity. States unable to defend themselves inevitably become dependent upon external powers and thereby compromise both their sovereignty and their freedom. Cosialls Ubach correctly identifies this continuity as evidence that military preparedness gradually evolved from a question of physical survival into a fundamental guarantee of political independence and constitutional self-government.

The article proceeds to examine the relationship between Vegetius and Carl von Clausewitz. While Clausewitz famously characterised war as the continuation of politics by other means, the author demonstrates that both thinkers ultimately subordinated military force to rational political objectives. Military preparedness exists not to glorify conflict but to safeguard the essential interests of the political community and preserve the State's capacity for autonomous decision-making. This continuity between classical Roman military thought and nineteenth-century strategic theory illustrates the remarkable longevity of Vegetius' intellectual influence.

One of the article's most original contributions lies in its application of Vegetius' maxim to contemporary deterrence theory. Modern deterrence seeks to convince potential aggressors that the costs of aggression will exceed any conceivable benefits. Consequently, military capabilities fulfil their principal strategic purpose precisely when they never need to be employed. The author convincingly argues that this logic closely mirrors Vegetius' original conception: the objective of preparation is not war itself but the prevention of war through credible defensive capacity. In this sense, Si vis pacem, para bellum emerges as one of the earliest formulations of what contemporary strategic studies would recognise as deterrence theory.

Methodologically, the article combines classical history, political philosophy, legal theory and strategic studies within an exceptionally concise yet coherent framework. Despite its limited length, the author succeeds in connecting Roman military literature with Hobbesian political philosophy, Thomistic ethics, Machiavellian statecraft and Clausewitzian strategic thought. This interdisciplinary approach considerably enhances the article's academic value while remaining accessible to readers from different disciplinary backgrounds.

The visual presentation of the article reinforces its principal message through the central quotation emphasising that "the best way to avoid conflict is to be prepared to confront it." Rather than functioning merely as an illustrative element, this statement encapsulates the article's normative argument that freedom depends upon security, and peace requires institutions capable of defending it. The layout successfully highlights the continuity between classical strategic wisdom and contemporary defence policy.

From a broader perspective, the article provides an important corrective to contemporary misunderstandings surrounding military preparedness. In democratic societies, defence policy is sometimes portrayed as inherently incompatible with peaceful international relations. Cosialls Ubach demonstrates precisely the opposite: for Vegetius, military capability acquires legitimacy only insofar as it protects peace, constitutional order and the conditions necessary for civil life. Far from promoting militarism, the maxim Si vis pacem, para bellum expresses a profoundly legal and institutional conception of security.

Overall, this article constitutes an elegant and intellectually stimulating contribution to the philosophy of defence and strategic studies. By recovering the original meaning of one of history's most frequently quoted military maxims, Andrés Miguel Cosialls Ubach successfully demonstrates that the relationship between peace, law and military preparedness remains as relevant today as it was during the final centuries of the Roman Empire. The study will be of particular interest to scholars of defence policy, legal philosophy, strategic studies, International Humanitarian Law and political theory seeking to understand the enduring intellectual foundations of contemporary security.

Abstract

This review examines Andrés Miguel Cosialls Ubach's philosophical and legal analysis of Flavius Vegetius Renatus' famous maxim Si vis pacem, para bellum. The article argues that Vegetius did not advocate militarism but instead understood military preparedness as an essential condition for preserving peace, political order and the rule of law. Through a comparative examination of Vegetius alongside Thomas Hobbes, Saint Augustine, Thomas Aquinas, Niccolò Machiavelli and Carl von Clausewitz, the study demonstrates the enduring influence of classical Roman strategic thought upon contemporary theories of deterrence, national security and defence policy. It concludes that credible military capability ultimately serves not to wage war but to prevent it.

De la Inteligencia Artificial al Transhumanismo en el Ámbito de la Defensa

2026

Autoría: Laína Gallego, José María ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 9 · Páginas: 76-79 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.21237952
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Laina Gallego, José María. “De la Inteligencia Artificial al Transhumanismo en el Ámbito de la Defensa.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 9, June 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

Review

Artificial intelligence and transhumanism have become two of the most influential concepts shaping contemporary debates on defence innovation, military ethics and emerging technologies. While artificial intelligence is already transforming operational planning, autonomous systems and decision-support capabilities, transhumanism introduces far more profound questions concerning the modification of the human condition itself. In this thought-provoking article, José María Laina Gallego explores the intellectual relationship between both phenomena, arguing that technological innovation in defence cannot be understood solely as a matter of operational effectiveness but must also be examined through the lenses of ethics, human dignity and legal regulation. By integrating philosophy, technology, defence studies and legal reflection, the article offers an original contribution to one of the most rapidly evolving areas of security policy.

The article begins by distinguishing artificial intelligence from broader technological progress. While technological innovation has accompanied human development throughout history, the author argues that artificial intelligence represents a qualitative transformation because of its capacity to learn, adapt and increasingly perform functions traditionally associated with human cognition. Nevertheless, the study carefully rejects the assumption that artificial intelligence reproduces genuine human intelligence. Instead, AI is presented as a distinct form of computational intelligence whose remarkable capabilities should not obscure its fundamental limitations, particularly regarding consciousness, common sense and moral judgement. This distinction provides the conceptual foundation upon which the remainder of the analysis is constructed.

One of the article's principal strengths lies in its examination of transhumanism as an extension of humanity's longstanding aspiration to overcome biological limitations. Rather than portraying transhumanism as a purely futuristic movement, Laina Gallego situates it within broader historical aspirations for self-improvement, longevity and enhanced physical and intellectual performance. The article recognises that advances in biotechnology, regenerative medicine, neurotechnology and artificial intelligence increasingly make some of these ambitions technically conceivable. However, it simultaneously questions whether every technological possibility necessarily constitutes genuine human progress, thereby introducing an ethical perspective that remains central throughout the study.

Particularly valuable is the discussion concerning the concept of human enhancement. The author distinguishes therapeutic interventions intended to restore normal human functions from enhancement technologies designed to surpass ordinary biological capacities. Examples such as genetic modification, cybernetic implants, neural interfaces and advanced prosthetic systems illustrate the increasingly blurred boundary between medical treatment and technological augmentation. Rather than adopting either an enthusiastic or alarmist position, the article encourages critical reflection regarding the ethical legitimacy of transforming human nature itself.

The implications for defence constitute the most original section of the study. Laina Gallego argues that military organisations may become among the principal beneficiaries of transhumanist technologies through the development of what might be described as "enhanced soldiers." Brain-computer interfaces, powered exoskeletons, accelerated tissue regeneration, sensory enhancement and cognitive augmentation are presented as technologies capable of significantly improving military performance. At the same time, the author correctly observes that these innovations inevitably generate profound legal and ethical questions concerning autonomy, responsibility, proportionality and the preservation of human dignity within armed forces. This balanced assessment distinguishes the article from more technologically deterministic approaches frequently encountered in discussions of military innovation.

The article further strengthens its analysis by introducing comparative perspectives drawn from Japan and the European Union. Japan is presented as one of the world's leading technological powers, particularly in robotics and artificial intelligence, while simultaneously illustrating the growing social and institutional interest surrounding transhumanism. Although Japanese technological development has not yet produced a fully articulated legal framework governing human enhancement, the country's leadership in robotics and assistive technologies provides an important reference point for future regulatory debates.

The discussion of the European Union is equally significant. Laina Gallego reviews the evolution of European policy documents concerning artificial intelligence, including the 2020 White Paper on Artificial Intelligence and the ethical guidelines adopted by the High-Level Expert Group on AI. Particular attention is devoted to the seven well-established requirements for trustworthy artificial intelligence, including human oversight, technical robustness, privacy, transparency, fairness, societal well-being and accountability. By examining these normative developments, the article demonstrates that Europe increasingly seeks to position itself as a global leader in human-centred artificial intelligence grounded in democratic values and fundamental rights.

One of the study's greatest contributions lies in its sustained emphasis on the role of law. Rather than viewing legal regulation as an obstacle to technological innovation, the author argues that law should actively shape the future development of artificial intelligence and transhumanist technologies before irreversible transformations occur. This preventive approach reflects an understanding that legal systems should not merely react to technological change but anticipate its consequences by establishing normative principles capable of protecting fundamental rights, human dignity and democratic accountability. Such an argument becomes particularly persuasive when applied to military technologies whose operational deployment may significantly affect both combatants and civilians.

The article also addresses one of the central philosophical dilemmas surrounding transhumanism: the meaning of improvement itself. Technological enhancement does not automatically equate to genuine human flourishing. According to the author, many proposed enhancements require careful ethical evaluation because they may fundamentally alter personal identity, social equality and even the definition of humanity itself. This philosophical reflection considerably enriches the legal discussion by demonstrating that regulation cannot be based exclusively upon technical feasibility or military utility.

Methodologically, the article combines philosophical analysis, legal reflection, comparative policy studies and defence technology within a coherent interdisciplinary framework. References to European Union policy documents, Japanese technological initiatives, bioethical scholarship and contemporary debates surrounding artificial intelligence provide a broad intellectual foundation while maintaining a clear focus upon defence applications. The interdisciplinary character of the study represents one of its principal academic strengths.

The accompanying visual material substantially reinforces the central argument. Images depicting electroencephalographic interfaces, brain-controlled prosthetic limbs, the Japanese Hybrid Assistive Limb (HAL) exoskeleton and military Human Universal Load Carrier (HULC) systems effectively illustrate the progressive convergence between artificial intelligence, robotics, neurotechnology and human enhancement. Rather than serving merely illustrative purposes, these examples demonstrate that many technologies commonly associated with speculative transhumanism are already emerging within contemporary medical and defence research.

From a broader strategic perspective, the article successfully demonstrates that future military superiority may depend not only upon increasingly autonomous systems but also upon the relationship between technological innovation and the human operator. Artificial intelligence and transhumanism therefore should not be analysed independently. Instead, both constitute interconnected dimensions of a broader transformation affecting defence policy, operational capability, military ethics and international regulation.

Overall, this article provides a timely and intellectually balanced examination of one of the most important emerging debates in contemporary defence studies. By combining technological analysis with ethical reflection and legal reasoning, José María Laina Gallego offers a comprehensive assessment of the opportunities and risks associated with artificial intelligence and transhumanism in the military domain. The study represents a valuable contribution for scholars of defence policy, military ethics, artificial intelligence governance, bioethics and international security seeking to understand the legal and philosophical implications of human enhancement in future armed forces.

Abstract

This review examines José María Laina Gallego's analysis of the relationship between artificial intelligence and transhumanism within the field of defence. The article explores how advances in artificial intelligence, neurotechnology, robotics and biotechnology are progressively converging towards forms of human enhancement with potential military applications. It analyses the ethical implications of enhanced soldiers, examines regulatory approaches adopted by the European Union and Japan, and argues that legal systems should anticipate rather than merely respond to technological transformation. By integrating philosophy, defence studies, bioethics and legal analysis, the study provides an important contribution to contemporary debates concerning human dignity, military innovation and the governance of emerging technologies.