Biblioteca Digital CODESEL

Publicaciones CODESEL

Catálogo científico de registros publicados en Zenodo

121 publicaciones encontradas

La explotación de hidrocarburos en el Sáhara Occidental

2026

Autoría: Fernandez González, Javier ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 8 · Páginas: 18-22 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19678769
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Fernández González, Javier. “La explotación de hidrocarburos en el Sáhara Occidental.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 8, April 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

The article “Hydrocarbon Exploitation in Western Sahara” offers a structured and legally grounded examination of one of the most complex intersections between international economic activity, territorial disputes, and the law of occupation. Situated at the crossroads of International Humanitarian Law (IHL), the law of self-determination, and the principle of permanent sovereignty over natural resources, the study provides a clear analytical framework to assess the legality of resource exploitation in contested territories.

The author begins with a technically informed overview of the hydrocarbon industry, emphasizing the structural dependency on capital-intensive infrastructure, transnational investment, and logistical networks. As illustrated in the offshore platform depicted on page 1, extraction activities are inseparable from broader industrial and geopolitical systems. This introductory section is particularly effective in grounding the legal analysis within the material realities of resource exploitation, thereby avoiding purely abstract reasoning.

The core legal argument emerges in the second section, where the author examines the normative constraints applicable to occupied territories. Drawing on Article 55 of the 1907 Hague Regulations, the study correctly characterizes the occupying power as a mere administrator and usufructuary of the territory’s resources, lacking sovereign entitlement. This interpretation is reinforced through reference to the Geneva Conventions and their Additional Protocols, which prohibit pillage and impose obligations to protect the civilian population. The invocation of UN General Assembly Resolution 1803 (XVII) further strengthens the argument by situating resource sovereignty within the broader doctrine of peoples’ rights, thereby linking IHL with the law of decolonization.

A particularly valuable contribution lies in the application of these principles to the specific case of Western Sahara. The article demonstrates that Morocco’s position as a de facto occupying power does not confer legal sovereignty over the territory or its resources. The continued absence of a self-determination referendum—supervised by MINURSO—reinforces the provisional and contested nature of Moroccan authority. The geopolitical map on page 3, which visually integrates resource zones, sovereignty claims, and UN deployment, effectively illustrates the fragmentation of control and the strategic importance of hydrocarbon prospects in shaping political positions.

The discussion of the Abraham Accords introduces a critical geopolitical dimension to the legal analysis. By highlighting the recognition of Moroccan sovereignty by the United States and Israel, the author exposes the tension between unilateral political recognition and the multilateral legal framework established by the United Nations. This section is particularly insightful, as it demonstrates how shifts in diplomatic alignments can indirectly affect the legal interpretation of resource exploitation without formally altering the applicable normative regime.

From a legal standpoint, one of the most compelling elements of the article is the reference to the 2002 UN legal opinion, which explicitly conditions the legality of resource exploitation on the consent and benefit of the local population. This principle—widely accepted in international practice—serves as the decisive معيار (criterion) for assessing the lawfulness of economic activities in non-self-governing territories. The author convincingly argues that any exploitation conducted without such consent risks violating international law, regardless of bilateral agreements between the occupying power and private corporations.

The empirical section detailing corporate involvement—Kosmos Energy, Cairn (Capricorn Energy), Chevron, and others—adds significant practical value to the study. The analysis of exploration activities, particularly in offshore blocks such as Boujdour Atlantique and Dakhla Atlantique (page 5), illustrates how multinational corporations operate within legally ambiguous environments. The fact that most projects remain in the exploration phase, with no confirmed commercially viable reserves, underscores both the economic uncertainty and the legal risk associated with such ventures.

This article represents a well-structured and analytically robust contribution to the study of resource exploitation in occupied territories. By integrating doctrinal analysis, geopolitical context, and empirical data, it provides a comprehensive framework for understanding the legal constraints governing hydrocarbon activities in Western Sahara. Its central thesis—that Morocco’s actions are legally limited by the principles of usufruct, self-determination, and the consent of the Sahrawi people—is convincingly supported and of clear relevance for both legal scholarship and policy debates.

¿Lex impotens? Realismo político vs derecho internacional

2026

Autoría: Serrano García, Eugenio ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 8 · Páginas: 1,12-17 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19678559
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Serrano García, Eugenio. “¿Lex impotens? Realismo político vs derecho internacional.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 8, April 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

The article “Lex impotens? Political Realism versus International Law” constitutes a theoretically grounded and analytically compelling reflection on one of the most enduring tensions in International Relations and Public International Law: the structural gap between normative legal frameworks and the strategic behavior of States. Framed within the intellectual tradition of political realism, the study interrogates the effective capacity of international law—particularly International Humanitarian Law (IHL)—to regulate State conduct in contexts of conflict and power competition.

From the outset, the author situates the problem within a context of geopolitical instability, emphasizing how contemporary conflicts reveal a persistent disjunction between legal obligation and political practice. Drawing on game theory—specifically the prisoner’s dilemma and Nash equilibrium—the article provides a persuasive analytical framework to explain why rational State actors may systematically defect from legal norms even when cooperation would yield collectively optimal outcomes. As illustrated in the table on page 5, mutual armament becomes the dominant strategy despite its suboptimal consequences, thus reflecting the structural incentives that undermine compliance with international law.

The conceptual backbone of the article lies in its engagement with classical and structural realism. The author mobilizes key figures such as Hans Morgenthau, Henry Kissinger, and Kenneth Waltz to argue that international politics is fundamentally governed by power, security, and national interest rather than legal or moral imperatives. In this sense, international law appears not as an autonomous normative order but as a contingent instrument, whose effectiveness is conditioned by the distribution of power within the international system. The invocation of Machiavelli reinforces this perspective, highlighting the enduring primacy of raison d’État over juridical constraints.

Importantly, the article does not dismiss international law outright but instead reframes its function. International Humanitarian Law is presented as a regulatory framework that mitigates the effects of armed conflict rather than preventing it, operating through the Geneva, Hague, and New York traditions. This doctrinal clarification is both accurate and necessary, as it avoids conflating the ius ad bellum with the ius in bello. However, the author convincingly demonstrates that even within its limited regulatory scope, IHL faces significant challenges of effectiveness due to the absence of centralized enforcement mechanisms.

A particularly valuable contribution of the article lies in its analysis of enforcement and accountability. The discussion of international institutions—especially the International Criminal Court and the United Nations Security Council—reveals the structural limitations inherent in a system lacking coercive authority. The example of the arrest warrant against Vladimir Putin underscores the gap between normative proclamation and practical enforcement, while the role of the veto power in the Security Council illustrates how institutional design reflects and perpetuates power asymmetries. These observations align closely with realist critiques of international organizations as instruments of hegemonic stabilization rather than neutral arbiters.

The article further explores the role of non-state actors and soft enforcement mechanisms, such as the International Committee of the Red Cross and human rights bodies. While acknowledging their normative and monitoring functions, the author correctly notes their limited capacity to compel compliance in the absence of State cooperation. This reinforces the central thesis: the effectiveness of international law ultimately depends on the political will of States, particularly those with significant power capabilities.

From a methodological standpoint, the integration of legal analysis with theoretical insights from political science is one of the article’s greatest strengths. The use of game theory, combined with classical realist theory, provides a multidimensional framework that enhances explanatory depth. The visual materials—such as the facsimile of the 1864 Geneva Convention (page 2) and the Nash equilibrium illustration (page 5)—further support the argument by grounding abstract concepts in historical and analytical representations.

“Lex impotens?” is a sophisticated and intellectually coherent contribution that successfully bridges legal doctrine and political theory. It offers a nuanced understanding of the limits of international law without falling into normative nihilism, instead situating law within the broader strategic environment in which it operates. For scholars and practitioners alike, the article provides a valuable framework for understanding why international law often fails to constrain State behavior—and under what conditions it may nevertheless retain relevance.

El ataque directo al Jefe de Estado enemigo: status jurídico en el ámbito del DICA

2026

Autoría: Cosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 8 · Páginas: 1-11 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19677765
Leer resumen

LEGAL REVIEW

Cosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel. “El ataque directo al Jefe de Estado enemigo: status jurídico en el ámbito del DICA.” Boletín CODESEL, vol. 2, no. 8, April 2026, ISSN-e: 3045-7750.

The article “The Direct Attack against the Enemy Head of State: Legal Status under International Humanitarian Law” offers a rigorous and conceptually sophisticated contribution to one of the most sensitive and contested issues in contemporary Law of Armed Conflict (LOAC): the legality of targeting political leadership in international armed conflicts. Written from a doctrinally grounded yet operationally aware perspective, the study succeeds in bridging classical legal theory with the evolving realities of precision warfare, centralized command structures, and emerging cyber capabilities.

At its core, the article advances a clear and defensible thesis: International Humanitarian Law (IHL) does not provide absolute immunity to enemy heads of State. Instead, their targetability must be assessed through the structural logic of the principle of distinction, as codified in Article 48 of Additional Protocol I. The author rejects simplistic or symbolic approaches based on the political prominence of the individual and instead situates the analysis within the binary architecture of LOAC—combatants versus civilians—thus restoring doctrinal clarity to a debate often clouded by political rhetoric.

One of the most significant strengths of the article lies in its systematic application of Dinstein’s “acid test.” This functional criterion—whether the individual participates in the planning or authorization of military operations—serves as the decisive threshold for determining lawful targetability. The article carefully distinguishes between status-based targeting (applicable to combatants or commanders-in-chief with effective operational authority) and conduct-based targeting (applicable to civilians, including most heads of State, only for such time as they directly participate in hostilities). This distinction is doctrinally sound and aligns with the prevailing interpretations of Sassòli, Melzer, and the ICRC Interpretive Guidance.

Particularly noteworthy is the treatment of temporality through the clause “for such time” in Article 51(3) of Additional Protocol I. The author convincingly develops a dynamic model of targetability, whereby the legal status of the individual fluctuates depending on their real-time involvement in operational decision-making. This approach reflects both doctrinal orthodoxy and operational necessity, especially in contemporary conflicts characterized by rapid decision cycles and digitally mediated command structures.

The article also provides an exceptionally precise analysis of the prohibition of perfidy as an absolute constraint on methods of warfare. Drawing on Hague law, Additional Protocol I, and the Tallinn Manual 2.0, the author delineates the boundary between lawful targeted killing and unlawful treacherous killing. The emphasis on the illegality of operations conducted under false civilian status (e.g., non-uniformed attackers) is particularly relevant, as it reaffirms the reciprocal nature of the principle of distinction—not only for the target but also for the attacker.

Another important contribution lies in the clear separation between IHL and International Criminal Law. The article effectively dismantles the common misconception that the personal immunity of heads of State entails protection from military targeting. By distinguishing between susceptibility to attack and susceptibility to prosecution, the author reinforces a fundamental doctrinal principle: legality under the ius in bello operates independently from questions of individual criminal responsibility.

Furthermore, the discussion of the “definite military advantage” requirement under Article 52(2) AP I introduces a critical perspective on the doctrine of decapitation warfare. The article does not merely accept its strategic rationale but subjects it to legal scrutiny, highlighting the empirical uncertainty surrounding its effectiveness and its potential incompatibility with the requirement of concrete and direct military advantage. This analytical move is particularly valuable, as it integrates legal reasoning with strategic realism.

Finally, the inclusion of accountability as a structural requirement for lawful targeting practices represents a forward-looking contribution. By incorporating Alston’s critique of secrecy and lack of transparency in targeted killing programs, the article extends the analysis beyond formal legality into the domain of enforceability and legitimacy, an area often neglected in doctrinal writings.

This article stands as a highly valuable and methodologically robust contribution to contemporary LOAC scholarship. It combines doctrinal precision, analytical depth, and strategic awareness, offering a coherent framework for assessing one of the most complex questions in modern warfare. Its integration of classical legal principles with emerging operational realities makes it particularly relevant for both academic and professional audiences engaged in the study and application of International Humanitarian Law.

El tiempo como arma en los conflictos

2026

Autoría: Cosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 7 · Páginas: 62-72 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18517625
Leer resumen

Legal and Politico-Strategic Review

Andrés Miguel Cosialls Ubach, “Time as a Weapon in Contemporary Conflicts”, CODESEL Bulletin (Cadre of Defense and Security Law), Vol. 2, No. 7, February 2026

This article offers an original and conceptually demanding re-interpretation of International Humanitarian Law (IHL) by identifying time—and more specifically delay—as a structurally under-theorized yet increasingly decisive instrument of violence in contemporary armed conflicts. Its central thesis is that modern warfare has learned to operate within the formal margins of IHL by shifting coercion away from overt denial or destruction toward the administration of temporal regimes that render protection materially ineffective while remaining formally lawful.

From a legal-doctrinal perspective, the article convincingly demonstrates that IHL has historically been constructed as a law of material limits—regulating weapons, targets, conduct, and protected persons—while treating time merely as an ethical intuition rather than as an autonomous legal category. The repeated use of open-textured temporal clauses such as “without delay,” “as soon as possible,” or “when circumstances permit” reflects an assumption that urgency is self-evident and that delay is exceptional. The author shows how this assumption has become untenable in contemporary conflicts, where delay is no longer accidental but systematically engineered.

A major contribution of the article lies in its systematic analysis of how delay operates across different protective regimes of IHL. In the context of wounded and sick persons, time is shown to function as a physiological boundary between survival and death. Assistance delivered outside the window of medical effectiveness is legally permitted yet materially void. The author persuasively argues that, in such cases, delay constitutes a form of harm in itself, transforming protection into a purely declaratory norm divorced from its life-preserving function.

The treatment of prisoners of war and detained persons further expands this logic. Here, delay becomes a tool of psychological disorientation and degradation rather than immediate physical harm. The prolonged postponement of registration, communication, evacuation, or medical care erodes the legal personality of the detainee without necessarily triggering any single, easily identifiable violation. The article exposes the profound difficulty IHL faces in addressing cumulative harm produced by temporal manipulation rather than discrete abusive acts.

Perhaps the most striking analysis concerns civilian populations and objects indispensable to survival, particularly in relation to starvation and humanitarian access. The article demonstrates how the classical prohibition of starvation as a method of warfare—anchored in destruction and blockade—fails to capture contemporary practices of temporalized deprivation. Food, water, and medical supplies are not denied outright but are delivered too late, too intermittently, or in insufficient volumes to reverse physiological degradation. The result is starvation by postponement, a phenomenon functionally equivalent to prohibited methods yet juridically elusive.

From a politico-strategic standpoint, the article situates these practices within the broader logic of hybrid and administrative warfare, where control is exercised through governance, procedure, and scheduling rather than brute force. Humanitarian corridors, evacuations, and relief operations are formally authorized but temporally structured to coincide with exhaustion, collapse, or forced displacement. Protection becomes performative; compliance is observed, while harm accumulates in the interval between permission and effectiveness.

The discussion of military necessity and proportionality is particularly sophisticated. The author shows how necessity has migrated from an exceptional justification to a permanent framework for managing humanitarian time. This transformation silently inverts proportionality analysis: harm is no longer concentrated in space or intensity but distributed over duration. The article thus calls for a reconceptualization of proportionality in temporal terms, focusing on cumulative and foreseeable effects rather than isolated decisions.

Equally important is the article’s contribution to evidentiary and accountability standards. By shifting the focus from singular acts to verifiable temporal regimes, the author proposes a methodology grounded in patterns, indicators, and interdisciplinary evidence drawn from medicine, nutrition, and humanitarian logistics. This approach aligns with existing developments in IHL concerning indiscriminate attacks and structural disproportionality, extending them coherently into the temporal domain.

Overall, this article constitutes a major doctrinal intervention in contemporary humanitarian law and conflict studies. It exposes a critical vulnerability in the legal architecture of protection and offers a rigorous conceptual framework for understanding delay as a method of warfare. By insisting that law must protect not only access but also timely effectiveness, the article re-anchors IHL in its fundamental purpose: the preservation of human life under conditions of extreme vulnerability. It is a work of high relevance for scholars, military legal advisers, humanitarian practitioners, and international accountability mechanisms.

Enkráteia: arquitectura invisible del mando y condición ontológica de la autoridad militar

2026

Autoría: Cosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 7 · Páginas: 73 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18517658
Leer resumen

Legal and Politico-Strategic Review (Philosophy of Military Law)

Andrés Miguel Cosialls Ubach, “Enkráteia: The Invisible Architecture of Command and the Ontological Condition of Military Authority”, CODESEL Bulletin (Cadre of Defense and Security Law), Vol. 2, No. 7, February 2026

This article constitutes a philosophically rigorous and normatively consequential inquiry into enkráteia (self-mastery) as the ontological precondition of military authority. Moving beyond technical doctrines of command and control, the author re-centers military leadership within a classical yet operationally relevant framework in which authority precedes coercion, and discipline originates internally before it can be imposed externally. The contribution is distinctive in that it bridges classical moral philosophy (Xenophon) with contemporary military practice, revealing a continuity often obscured by technological and procedural emphases.

From the standpoint of the philosophy of military law, the article advances a decisive claim: the legitimacy of command is not exhausted by formal rank, legal mandate, or institutional hierarchy. Rather, it rests upon a functional legitimacy grounded in the commander’s capacity for self-government. Drawing on Xenophon’s Memorabilia, the author demonstrates that enkráteia is not an ascetic virtue detached from action, but a structural condition of lawful command, without which authority degenerates into mere domination and obedience into mechanical compliance. This insight has direct implications for how military law understands responsibility, discretion, and trust.

The analysis carefully dismantles the misconception that self-mastery implies emotional suppression. Instead, enkráteia is presented as the subordination of passions to judgment, a distinction of paramount importance in military decision-making. Fear, anger, ambition, and desire are not eradicated; they are rendered non-sovereign. In legal-philosophical terms, the commander’s will is constituted as a norm-creating agency only insofar as it is not captured by affect. This reframing clarifies why lawful orders require more than formal validity: they require a stable moral subject capable of sustaining judgment under pressure.

A central philosophical contribution of the article lies in its articulation of interiority as the first site of discipline. External discipline—regulations, procedures, sanctions—appears here as a projection of an antecedent inner order. The author’s analysis resonates with foundational themes in military law concerning obedience and accountability: when orders are issued from emotional volatility, the chain of command becomes legally intact yet normatively brittle. The well-known military aphorism—“order and counter-order: disorder”—is thus given a philosophical grounding that illuminates why legal correctness alone cannot secure operational coherence.

From a politico-strategic perspective, the article situates enkráteia within the conditions of contemporary, distributed warfare, where decisions are often taken far from the battlefield and under persistent informational and moral pressure. In such environments, the absence of reciprocal risk heightens the danger of impulsive or unreflective action. Enkráteia emerges as a professional competence of the first order, enabling commanders to maintain proportionality, restraint, and clarity amid uncertainty. This has direct implications for compliance with International Humanitarian Law, particularly regarding precaution, distinction, and the management of escalation.

The article also advances a compelling account of credibility as the practical currency of command. Credibility is not decreed by statute nor guaranteed by insignia; it is accumulated over time through consistent, controlled conduct. From a jurisprudential angle, this insight reframes authority as a relational norm sustained by trust. Units cohere not because they fear punishment, but because they recognize a stable axis of judgment in their leaders. Enkráteia thus functions as a systemic stabilizer, ordering collective behavior without recourse to excessive coercion.

Normatively, the article’s most far-reaching implication concerns the protection of life. By linking the commander’s self-government to the safety of those commanded, the author establishes a direct line between moral failure and legal risk. A commander who cannot govern himself endangers not only his authority, but the lives entrusted to him. This claim elevates enkráteia from ethical ideal to juridically relevant condition, inviting reflection on how military education, evaluation, and responsibility regimes might better account for the moral architecture of command.

Overall, this contribution stands as a philosophically grounded and operationally lucid intervention in the theory of military authority. It restores to military law a dimension often overshadowed by technique: the formation of the commanding subject. By identifying enkráteia as the invisible architecture of command, the article offers a durable criterion for authority that remains valid across technological epochs and doctrinal shifts. It is essential reading for scholars of military law, leadership ethics, and the jurisprudence of armed forces.

Violaciones graves de derechos humanos y protección internacional: el caso de Irán a la luz de la Responsabilidad de Proteger

2026

Autoría: Cisneros Cristóbal, Paula ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 7 · Páginas: 56-61 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18517586
Leer resumen

Legal and Politico-Strategic Review

Paula Cisneros Cristóbal, “Grave Human Rights Violations and International Protection: The Case of Iran in Light of the Responsibility to Protect”, CODESEL Bulletin (Cadre of Defense and Security Law), Vol. 2, No. 7, February 2026

This article delivers a rigorous and normatively sophisticated analysis of the systematic repression of fundamental rights in the Islamic Republic of Iran, examined through the conceptual and legal framework of the Responsibility to Protect (R2P). Its central contribution lies in demonstrating that large-scale and sustained violations of human rights—occurring outside the context of an armed conflict—may nevertheless activate the material thresholds of international protection, thereby challenging restrictive interpretations of sovereignty and non-intervention.

From a legal standpoint, the article is firmly grounded in treaty law and customary international law. The author carefully reconstructs Iran’s obligations under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), emphasizing that these obligations are binding irrespective of domestic political or religious structures. The analysis of non-derogable rights—most notably the right to life and the absolute prohibition of torture—is doctrinally precise and reflects the settled jurisprudence of the Human Rights Committee and other UN mechanisms.

A key strength of the article is its treatment of state violence as a systemic policy rather than a series of isolated abuses. Drawing on reports from the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights and the Independent International Fact-Finding Mission established by the UN Human Rights Council, the author convincingly argues that the repeated use of lethal force, mass arbitrary detentions, torture, and judicial persecution reveals a coordinated pattern of repression attributable to state authorities. This characterization is crucial, as it underpins the legal qualification of such conduct as potentially amounting to crimes against humanity, even in the absence of armed conflict.

The discussion of the death penalty is particularly incisive. While acknowledging that international law does not categorically prohibit capital punishment, the article demonstrates that Iran’s practices—especially executions following unfair trials, vague national security charges, or confessions extracted under torture—constitute arbitrary deprivations of life under Article 6 of the ICCPR. This analysis effectively situates the death penalty within a broader architecture of repression rather than treating it as a discrete penal issue.

From a gender perspective, the article makes a significant contribution by highlighting the gendered nature of repression in Iran. The disproportionate targeting of women and girls—through enforcement of mandatory veiling laws, sexual violence in detention, and judicial persecution of female activists—is correctly analysed as a violation of the principles of equality and non-discrimination, and as a potential element of the crime of persecution under international criminal law. This dimension reinforces the argument that repression operates across multiple, intersecting axes of vulnerability.

The article’s engagement with the Responsibility to Protect doctrine is both cautious and analytically robust. The author correctly notes that R2P is a norm of soft law rather than a binding treaty obligation, while emphasizing its status as a guiding principle of collective response to mass atrocity crimes. By situating Iran within the material scope of R2P—due to credible evidence of crimes against humanity—the article reframes sovereignty as responsibility rather than privilege. At the same time, it realistically assesses the political obstacles to coercive action, particularly the structural constraints of the UN Security Council.

Importantly, the article avoids equating R2P with military intervention. Instead, it highlights a spectrum of non-coercive and semi-coercive measures, including international investigations, evidence preservation, targeted sanctions, diplomatic isolation, and support for civil society. This approach underscores the preventive and accountability-oriented dimensions of R2P, which are often overshadowed by debates on the use of force.

From a politico-strategic perspective, the article situates Iran’s internal repression within a broader regional and international security context. Iran’s role in Middle Eastern conflicts and its contentious relationship with the nuclear non-proliferation regime mean that internal human rights violations cannot be neatly separated from concerns of regional stability and international peace and security. This linkage strengthens the legitimacy of sustained international scrutiny and engagement.

Overall, this contribution stands out as a methodologically rigorous and normatively compelling study that bridges international human rights law, international criminal law, and security studies. It provides a clear demonstration of how grave human rights violations within a functioning state can generate legitimate international concern and potential responsibility under R2P, while also exposing the limits and selectivity of the current collective security system. The article is of high relevance for scholars and practitioners working on human rights protection, atrocity prevention, and the evolving meaning of sovereignty in international law.

La doctrina rusa de la disuasión estratégica tras la expiración del New START

2026

Autoría: Cosialls Ubach, Andrés Miguel ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 7 · Páginas: 51-55 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18517540
Leer resumen

Legal and Politico-Strategic Review

Andrés Miguel Cosialls Ubach, “Russian Strategic Deterrence Doctrine after the Expiration of New START”, CODESEL Bulletin (Cadre of Defense and Security Law), Vol. 2, No. 7, February 2026

This article provides a dense, systematically argued reconstruction of Russian strategic deterrence doctrine in the aftermath of the expiration of the New START Treaty, identifying the end of the bilateral arms control regime not as a sudden rupture, but as the juridical formalization of a pre-existing doctrinal and political shift. Its core contribution lies in explaining Russian strategic rationality on its own terms, avoiding mirror-imaging and normative reductionism.

From a legal perspective, the article challenges the widespread assumption that strategic stability is primarily a product of binding legal instruments and verification regimes. The author convincingly demonstrates that, in Russian doctrinal thinking, law functions as a contingent stabilizer rather than as the constitutive foundation of deterrence. New START is thus portrayed not as a guarantor of equilibrium per se, but as a mechanism whose stabilizing effects depended on a shared political context that Moscow now considers irreversibly eroded. This reframing is analytically rigorous and essential for understanding why treaty expiration does not automatically translate into perceived instability from the Russian viewpoint.

A central legal–strategic axis of the article concerns asymmetry and reversibility within arms control regimes. The analysis of “upload potential” asymmetries—whereby U.S. conventional platforms could be rapidly reconverted into nuclear delivery systems—illustrates how formal numerical parity can coexist with structural imbalance. This argument is doctrinally significant, as it exposes the limits of quantitative ceilings as legal proxies for strategic equality in technologically diversified environments.

The article’s treatment of the suspension and expiration of New START as strategic signaling acts is particularly strong. Drawing on deterrence theory and Russian doctrinal literature, the author explains how the deliberate withdrawal from transparency mechanisms introduces calibrated uncertainty into the adversary’s calculations. From this perspective, legal opacity becomes a deterrent resource, not a defect. This analysis illuminates the evolving relationship between law, uncertainty, and coercion in contemporary strategic practice.

One of the most original contributions of the article is its examination of integrated strategic deterrence. Russian doctrine is shown to conceptualize deterrence as a unified system combining nuclear forces, conventional long-range strike capabilities, economic resilience, energy security, information control, and technological sovereignty. This holistic approach challenges Western compartmentalization between military and civilian domains and has profound implications for international law, particularly regarding the protection of critical infrastructure and the blurring of traditional distinctions between armed conflict and strategic competition.

The discussion of limited nuclear use and expanded escalation thresholds is handled with notable analytical restraint. Rather than reproducing simplified narratives of “escalate to de-escalate,” the article situates Russian thinking within a framework of existential risk management. Nuclear use is presented as a latent function of system-wide deterrence, reserved for scenarios involving systemic collapse rather than tactical advantage. This interpretation has significant consequences for legal assessments of proportionality, necessity, and escalation control under international humanitarian law.

From a politico-strategic standpoint, the article situates post–New START deterrence within a multidomain environment characterized by high uncertainty and contested norms. The treatment of radiological risk, particularly in relation to civilian nuclear infrastructure, expands the notion of the nuclear threshold beyond weapon detonation to include catastrophic functional disruption. This reconceptualization is strategically and legally consequential, as it reframes certain forms of indirect coercion as quasi-nuclear events within deterrence logic.

Overall, this contribution stands out as a methodologically disciplined and conceptually demanding study that bridges international law, strategic theory, and doctrinal analysis. It provides an indispensable framework for understanding Russian strategic behavior in a post-treaty environment and offers critical insights into the future of arms control, escalation management, and strategic stability beyond formal legal regimes.

Referencias sobre el Inicio del Establecimiento de Relaciones Diplomáticas entre Japón y España

2026

Autoría: Laína Gallego, José María ORCID ↗

Tipo: Journal article · Revista: Boletín CODESEL · ISSN-e: 3045-7750 · Volumen: 2 · Número: 7 · Páginas: 47-50 · Idioma(s): spa · DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.18517495
Leer resumen

Legal and Politico-Strategic Review

José María Laína Gallego, “References on the Beginning of the Establishment of Diplomatic Relations between Japan and Spain”, CODESEL Bulletin (Cadre of Defense and Security Law), Vol. 2, No. 7, February 2026

This article offers a carefully documented and historically grounded analysis of the legal foundations of diplomatic relations between Japan and Spain, focusing on the 1868 Treaty of Friendship, Commerce and Navigation signed in Kanagawa. Its principal contribution lies in situating this bilateral instrument within the broader transformation of Japan’s international legal personality during the mid-nineteenth century, while highlighting its significance as a constitutive act of diplomatic recognition and normalization rather than a merely commercial agreement.

From a legal perspective, the article convincingly demonstrates that the 1868 Treaty must be understood as a treaty of establishment of diplomatic relations in the strict sense of international law. The close reading of Articles 1 and 2—addressing perpetual peace and friendship, as well as the reciprocal appointment of diplomatic and consular agents—supports the conclusion that the treaty created a durable framework of inter-state relations. The author’s emphasis on these provisions is doctrinally sound and corrects interpretations that reduce the treaty to a sectoral trade instrument.

The historical reconstruction preceding the treaty is not merely contextual but legally relevant. By tracing early contacts—such as the 1609 shipwreck of the Spanish galleon San Francisco and the humanitarian rescue of its crew by Japanese ama—the article illustrates the existence of pre-diplomatic interactions that foreshadowed later legal normalization. Equally important is the analysis of Japan’s prolonged isolation (sakoku) and its termination following the U.S.–Japan Treaty of 1854, which the author correctly identifies as a structural precondition for Spain’s subsequent diplomatic engagement.

A particularly noteworthy contribution of the article is its examination of religious freedom under Article 4 of the 1868 Treaty. The author persuasively argues that the recognition of the right of Spanish residents in Japan to freely practice their religion—including the construction of places of worship—constituted a remarkably advanced legal provision for its time. This analysis situates the treaty within the genealogy of human rights protection, highlighting how bilateral diplomacy functioned as an early vector for the international circulation of fundamental freedoms prior to their systematic codification in twentieth-century international law.

From a politico-strategic standpoint, the article implicitly situates the treaty within the dynamics of imperial competition, maritime connectivity, and commercial expansion in the Pacific. Spain’s interest in Japan is convincingly linked to its presence in the Philippines and other Pacific territories, underscoring how geographic proximity and maritime routes shaped diplomatic priorities. At the same time, Japan’s selective engagement with European powers is presented as a strategic process of controlled integration into the international system rather than passive opening.

The discussion of the subsequent 1897 Treaty of Friendship and General Relations further reinforces the argument that diplomatic relations between Spain and Japan evolved through legal continuity rather than rupture, preserving core elements such as religious freedom while adapting to changing international conditions. This longitudinal perspective enhances the article’s analytical depth and confirms its relevance beyond purely historical inquiry.

Overall, this contribution stands out as a methodologically rigorous and legally attentive study that bridges diplomatic history and international law. It demonstrates how bilateral treaties functioned as foundational instruments of legal personality, recognition, and normative transfer in the nineteenth-century international order. The article is of particular value for scholars interested in diplomatic law, treaty practice, the history of international relations, and the legal dimensions of cross-cultural engagement.